Entroper said: Battalion Wars. I had heard really great things about this game, and I found it NEW in the box for $10, so I picked it up. Unfortunately, it turned out to be a half-assed RTS with severe issues in control, friendly AI, and interface, and it couldn't quite pull off the cartoony feel it was going for either. |
+1. Though I've only played BW2, I feel the exact same way.
I'd say Team Fortress 2. The art style is simply great and how they make each character class have a personality is a feat few games succeed at. The maps have a certain feel that is just oozing style, which I think is fantastic. However this game fails as the gameplay is a more or less carbon copy of team fortress classic but each class feels weaker. There are no new classes and each class now feels gimped to the point where you are severly limited in what you can and cannot do. I guess with the hype surrounding this game's release I was expecting much, much more. The good news is the rest of the orange box is an unparalleled experience.
I guess if i had gone into it wanting only a graphical/stylistic update along with gameplay tweaks and modifications this would be fantastic. I personally thought (wishful thinking, i guess) they would overhaul the classes and their abilities to make the gameplay fresh and entertaining. I was wrong.