The best part of this thread was semantics being used it for fanboyism. Semantics FTW!

OT, I haven't played either. We can expect both games will be "big" on their respective consoles. We'll see which is "bigger." Right after I go measure my...

Bigger franchise? right now it's a TIE, 3 games each.

or

Bigger franchise? Animal Crossing, that's 14 letters + a space = 15. God of War, that's 8 letters + 2 spaces = 10. AC WINS.

AC on the Wii will have LTD sales of over 5 million easily. It could get to 10 million.

GOW on PS3 will be lucky to get past 3 million.

 Ah, now I get the thread. Thanks.

Who popularly demanded this thread?

soriku

Edit: Well he said  " Go make a thread that asks which is bigger AC or GoW and you will see how many people will say AC."

in the UK

an "austin allegro" sold more than a "mclaren F1" yet the "mclaren F1" is an entire planet apart from the "austin allegro"

i think the above^ sums this up quite clearly

 Ok, so now that Kingofwale is crying in a corner in the fetal position, wrapped up in a canadian flag like a tortilla...

 It is irrelevant who the game sold to or why. I can say Mario Baseball is bigger than God of War because God of War only sells to people who buy Sony products. You can't exclude a bunch of people because you dislike them. A game franchise size can only be objectively measured by sales. It is essentially measuring just how popular the game is. Popularity is not diminished because the majority of your supporters come from a single demographic.

 I miss the days when you were banned. Your ridiculous method of arguing is so unbelievably annoying. You throw out ludicrous claims one way, and end the arguement trying to straw man the people correcting you.