Call of Duty 4, without a doubt.

Call of Duty 4

Call of Duty 4 is what all FPS's aspire to be like.

Call of duty 4 no question

I'm a big fan of controls. To me, everything else is gravy. So, I would have to go with CoD4 on this one. For a non-Wii console, the controls in CoD4 should be what all FPS dev.'s should aim for.

CoD, even though being one of those alien bug dudes is kind of fun, except setting yourself on fire. Wait that is fun.

That's funny because unless I can customize the controls, I usually hate them, and in CoD4 I was forced to use the default control scheme. I like putting jump on L1 or the LB so I can jump shoot aim and move without moving any of my fingers. It's how I give myself an automatic edge in many of the games I play.

I'd dare to say COD4 even without having played Resistance.
Of course I'm not entirely serious, but I do know that a lot more people think COD4 is a lot more fun, and that it is the best 'generic' FPS I have ever seen (yes I've played it - who hasn't?). Call of Duty's atmosphere, realism, and perfection are just too good for any FPS game to compete with (more story-driven, non-generic games like Bioshock except).

Call of Duty 4 is better in everyway.