On your "About Us" page, there is a grammar mistake in the sentence right after the one telling you to report mistakes. Bad form.
The multitude of hearts is distasteful. If you walk into a bedroom, which would you rather see as a bed sheet: A smooth red satin sheet or a fluffy looking cotton sheet with hearts all over it? If you are older than 12, the choice is fairly clear.
Lots of default blue links make the website look cheap. Even switching some link colors or changing up a bit within reason would give it a more polished look.
Having no blogs/polls/...etc makes the site feel unfinished. You should have made a few before launching just to have some content in those sections even if it wasn't much.
Also, ask yourself why people will come to your website. Find out what the people visiting go to most and streamline it to make it simpler. If one particular section gets more hits than any other, highlight it and build off it.