A game like MGS will never be top of gamerankings. It is more love or hate then others games.

while i agree  i must say that i feel mario 64 was more revolutionary than ocarina of time

No, in another 2 gens down the track OoT will still be thought of as the greatest game ever and mgs4 will just be one of many action/stealth games.

No, but then u have to look at how many people reviewed OOT, it was like 30. Now a days every game has like 60 reviews attached to it therefore making it alot harder to top OOT, so in my opinion OOT shouldnt be treated as the best game ever as it was reviewed by so little people.

Nah, eventually the latecoming reviews from ethics-worried parties will shoot down the average like it happens with all violent games.

no sorry if you want that to happen.

Only Nintendo fans care about OoT hanging onto top place. Sooner or later OoT will fall.

BTW: I had only heard of OoT when I found out about it on VGChartz and the nth threads of it holding top spot, losing top spot. blah blah blah. 

OoT is flawless in the basics of a video game, but lacks a lot in the substance department.  There's no feeling or purpose in the pacing of the game.  You're just kind of there so to speak. 

Replay value is not the most important thing in a game.  It keeps it lasting, but it depends on how rewarding and useful differencials(ways to play the game, sidequests and minigames etc.) in the game are.  

After beating MGS4 I can honestly tell you that this game won't be gathering dust in hardly anyone's collection for a long time.   

Not a chance

as ive said before game review sites are a waist of time, the only thing that matters is your own opinion of a game.