If anyone would provide some game suggestions it would be most appreciated.  I like FPSs, good storyline games, WRPGs like Bioware.  I have all the Halo's, Mass Effect w/DLC, All console COD's except for 360 COD2 and COD3 though from what I here 3 is a Treyarch blunder, History Channel Civil War, my game list is on my profile halogamer1989--I don't want to list everything.  I was thinking of getting Oblivion GOTY, maybe Orange Box though I don't know if I would like itm, or GTA 4 since it would be my first GTA, or a racing game, MSFT racing wheel FTW - I'm 19 and didn't buy many games in my teens.  I am not a game noob but am in college at the present (for game art and design) and am a little strapped on cash.  Suggestions?

Orange Box is great. Good multiplayer in team fortress 2, good story in halflife 2 series and best game last year in Portal.

If you want a budget title thats pretty good FPS pick up FEAR from 2006. Great story and even better gameplay... Shouldn't be more than 15 bucks these days.

Otehrwise I also really liked Overlord, that should be cheap.

If you absolutley can't buy a PS3 i'd recomend Gears of War it's quite old but I don't think it's in your list .

 And what would he play on PS3 that is better than what he can already get on 360?

 I want to get to sleep today before 12 , sorry but you'll just have to use google.

 heh...nice cop out.

Definitely Gears and BioShock based on your list and preferences. Plus they are cheap now.

 I could make a list of at least 10 games without blinking.

I would highly recommend The Darkness as well. Under-rated and cheap.

I know you can, but I'm not sure its wise as its kinda like getting in to a pissing match with a skunk.

You realize the whole premise of PS3 at this point is the "future" games coming out this year or next year. Most people should realize that as far as back catalog is concerned (which is what he asked for) , PS3 is still inferior to 360.