Netanyahu cabinet votes in favour of firing Shin Bet security chief
As we previously reported, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu held a cabinet meeting on Thursday night in order to vote on the dismissal of Ronen Bar, the chief of Israel’s Shin Bet domestic security agency.
Israel’s prime minister’s office has now confirmed that his cabinet has approved Bar’s sacking, with his final day slated for April 10. At the meeting, Netanyahu said he had “lost faith” in Bar since the Shin Bet had failed to prevent the Hamas-led October 7 attacks and accused Bar of being “soft” on captive negotiations, according to his office.
The vote represents the first time in Israel’s history that a government has fired Shin Bet’s chief.
Bar alleges the move stems from his refusal to meet Netanyahu’s demands for “personal loyalty”.
His removal has caused an uproar among Israel’s opposition, with Avigdor Liberman, the leader of the Yisrael Beytenu party, slamming Netanyahu for “doing exactly what our enemies dream of – fighting the Shin Bet head”.
Protesters opposing Bar’s sacking also clashed with police in front of Netanyahu’s office on Thursday.
Translation: Israeli occupation police officers smash the windows of Israeli demonstrators’ cars in Jerusalem during a protest against the dismissal of the head of the Shin Bet and the resumption of the war on Gaza.
First time in Israel’s history that head of Shin Bet intelligence service fired
This is an incredibly unprecedented move in Israel. It is the first time that a government has voted to dismiss the head of its domestic, internal security services.
What we know is that the Israeli cabinet convened very late in the evening – around 11pm local time (21:00 GMT) – and the vote was unanimous.
However, Ronen Bar was not present in this meeting and instead submitted a quite scathing letter to ministers within the government noting that his presence in the meeting would not be because he didn’t actually find these provisions legal, and saying his dismissal from his post needed to happen in some sort of orderly structure with a lot of other people, who needed to be involved given just how senior his position is.
He also noted that the Israeli prime minister is trying to evade a lot of different things, which means Netanyahu is trying to evade an internal investigation into the security failures that Israel had on October 7 and he has also tried to push forward his own political agenda.
Ronen Bar said that Netanyahu wanted him to negotiate with mediators on a ceasefire deal in Gaza but without coming to any sort of deal. And he was side-lined from those talks about a month ago and, instead, replaced with one of Netanyahu’s confidants so that the Israeli prime minister could get his agenda on the negotiating table.
This is surely an unprecedented step in Israeli history. It’s getting a lot of backlash from the opposition.