Well, it's been a month since SSBB came out so I think it's time for this thread...

We all know the "Big 3" were very hyped and stuff, but which do you think is the best?

Which was the most influential? The most important?

I personally think Super Mario Galaxy wins almost every category, it's a brilliant game, with some of the best game design in years, and it proved that Mario can still be Game of the Year, and that Nintendo can still put out a AAAA game. It's also the first widely accepted "E" Game of the Year in 7 years! Truly innovative, and I think we'll still be talking about it 5 years from now. It's also IMO my favorite game ever. What Super Mario 64 and Sunshine should have been, SMG is the true evolution of 2D Mario.

As for Super Smash Bros. Brawl, I find it very good but, a month later, it's become horribly boring to me. My friends don't like the game, it gets boring fighting against CPUs and the online is unuseable pretty much.

And MP3...I never played it.

Definitely Super Mario Galaxy for the best of the 3 though, in pretty much everyway.

But what do you think? Which is your favorite? Which do you think is the most influential?

Although I don't think Brawl will be GOTY, my hat goes off to it....
may not been as good as people hyped it to be, but they ruined the gaming experience for believing that Brawl might get an insane amount of characters.

It's addictive though. Wide variety of music, good adventure mode, good multiplayer, stage creator is okay, and the online needs improvement, but is acceptable.

ssbb

Galaxy definately. MP3 and SSBB are both awesome, but Galaxy is deservedly one of the most critically acclaimed games ever. It is brilliant.

Super Smash Bros. Brawl.   Easily.

my favorite is SSBB the replay value and sheer content in the game is through the roof

So.. what exactly is this thread about?

Can you read? It should be horribly obvious.

SSBB
MP:3 (Although I can't figure where the hell I'm going half the time!)
SMG (Not as Enjoyable for me...)

SMG for me. MP3 was great but had a few flaws. SSBB is feature-packed but at the core is really the same game as Melee.