The problem with these threads is that the Nintendo fans don't explore the PlayStation library and the PS fans can't be bothered to experiment with everything Nintendo has to offer. So you just get folks voting along party lines.

Imo persona 5 > zelda botw. And sony has more quality exclusives. Would you rather have zelda botw and mario odyssey or nioh, horizon, Persona 5, yakuza 0, yakuza kiwami, gravity rush 2, ff12 zodiac age, crash n sane just to name a few. 

Nah, everybody won this year, because it was plentiful of pretty good games in every platform.

I agree though, that the first party Nintendo output this year is stellar. Let's see how they can top this year in 2018, but it seems hard to do.

Yes. Yes he is citing an article. It's from an "opinion piece" that appeared on N4G.

http://vgculturehq.com/nintendo-has-won-2017/

Nintendo killed Sony in first party. Played most of what both had to offer, no contest.

What you personally think is totally different thing, we have scores like proof what more objectively is better. Yes Sony has more exclusives (that actualy isnt strange becuse its few years on market so has stronger support and is was 2 monts more on market than Switch this year,), but Nintendo has higher quality exclusives so far, Zelda BotW and Mario Odyssey will be above everything Sony had this year despite fact that PS4 will have tons of games this year. Also from games you mentioned only two are Sony games, so Nintendo definitely easily beate Sony in quality of games for this year.

So far it only has 1 exclusive that is above every sony exclusives and that is zelda botw. I dont know about you but id rather have nioh, Persona 5, yakuza kiwami, yakuza 0, gravity rush 2, ff12 zodiac age, crash n sane, kingdom hearts 2.8, kingdom hearts 1.5 and 2.5 and many many others that already been released this year. And not to mention all the quality 3rd party games that switch doesnt have. Sony won 2017

Just based on perceived hype alone, it could be argued that Switch indeed nailed 2017

^This is actualy very insightful, listen to this person 

So far only one that is above any PS4 game not just exclusives, and soon we will have second. I mentioned one game thats released and game that will be released soon that will above any other Sony game, but offcourse that Nintendo didnt had only those games that are good this year, while you bascily mentione almost evre PS4 exclusive this year. Lol, of course that PS4 and even XB1 easily beat Switch and 3DS if we talk about 3rd party games, but if we talk about quality of exlusives, not to mentine games made from house, result is quite difrent. Nintendo will easily wins like top quality developer this year, not just Sony but evre other company on market.