By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics - Turkey to teach children true meaning of 'jihad' in schools

VGPolyglot said:
vivster said:

Patriotism is no different from being proud of something you're a part of. Like being proud of what your friends and family do. Or being proud of winning a Hearthstone tournament. You were not directly involved in those achievements but there is nothing wrong with taking pride in it and being happy that're somehow part of it.

I really think you're confusing patriotism with nationalism.

Why would you take pride in something that you're not involved in? Pride is satisfaction derived from one's own achievements, so if you're not involved with the achievement it doesn't make sense.

What about a parent being proud of their child's accomplishments.

They are proud of their child. They are not proud of themselves for possibly having a hand in what their child did if they even did have a hand in it.

Your definition of pride is very selfish.



Around the Network
VGPolyglot said:
Nationalism and patriotism, two ideas that I'm very opposed to.

This is far different than that. This is radical religion infecting the secular Turkey. Is there anywhere left in the middle east that is relatively normal?



Made a bet with LipeJJ and HylianYoshi that the XB1 will reach 30 million before Wii U reaches 15 million. Loser has to get avatar picked by winner for 6 months (or if I lose, either 6 months avatar control for both Lipe and Hylian, or my patrick avatar comes back forever).

@patriotism discussion

There is not much wrong with a patriot who loves to see "his" country winning at the Olympic Games or stuff like that. He doesn't harm anyone nor does that "fighting for your country" in sport harm anyone as long as it is fair play. Patriotism isn't automatically bad if it doesn't go to far. It doesn't have to mean the guy believes his country is better as other countries or anything.

Chauvinism on the other hand is definitely wrong.



VGPolyglot said:
psychicscubadiver said:

That's not even the main thing. How will infrastructure and living conditions remain at any reasonable level? Their are jobs, whether risky or unpleasant that people do not want to do. Without a currency system in place (or a brutally oppressive government like the Soviet Union under Stalin) how do you induce people to do those jobs? Heck, how do you induce peopleto do even regular jobs when it would be quicker and easier to use violence to obtain what they want? Ancom has never worked historically. Even the hippies communes based along those ideas fell apart typcially within years.

As, I said, mutal aid. And violence would not be an ideal option, because it's much harder to become more advanced when you're constantly in conflict. And ancom hasn't worked historically because it was bordered by hostile forces that eventually attacked and overwhelmed them.

crissindahouse said:

Yes, there are humans who care for each other but those never really stopped the humans who are not like that.

What is your grand plan? All good guys work together to stop all bad guys, the bad guys will just stop to be bad because the good guys say it and everyone will work together? We will live all together on the planet and everything will just work well with everyone responsible for himself and his orange tree which he always does get enough oranges from without anyone else taking them?

Common...

Even small villages in a jungle have one or more "leader" for a reason. It doesn't work otherwise over a long time. And if even these small villages with people who are still living like thousand years ago have some people considered to be "above" the others, how in the world do you expect a city with millions of people to function just on the basis of "we all live friendly together and teamwork will do it for us"? 

Man, you can get robbed on the street with 100 people who see it and nobody will help you but you think you could work together with them without criminals taking over your area...

I don't believe that there's such thing is inherently bad people, which is why I said it's more complicated than that.

What prevents violence? You have not offered any possible counter to that simple consideration. The society you are depicting depends upon all of its members holding utter trust in each other despite the fact that some people will make bad choices. No has to be inherently bad to make a bad choice or to use violence to achieve what they want. If my family were without food or shelter, I would fight or steal for them. And if you want to counter that with the idea of 'mutual aid' then you have to somehow create a post scarity world. Which gets back to my earlier point (which was unaddressed) about how you get people to do risky or unpleseant jobs without some sort of impetus (be it money or coercison).

Why would you take pride in something that you're not involved in? Pride is satisfaction derived from one's own achievements, so if you're not involved with the achievement it doesn't make sense.

So I can't be proud when my brother gets a scholarship or my friend wins a tournament? Pride is more than self-interest. It can extend to whoever or whatever you care about. I am proud of my city, my state, my country when we do something right. And I am shamed when we do something wrong. I can identify with them as part of my group. No man is an island, afterall.



fatslob-:O said:
vivster said:

They have the same basis but a completely different attitude and intent. Like an imam in a soup kitchen and an ISIS fighter.

Patriotism and nationalism are both based on pride but they take a completely opposite approach. Which takes me back to my original comment. Patriotism has never hurt anyone, nationalism has.

Patriotism and nationalism are literally synonyms ... 

Just what exactly is the difference between liking or being devoted to one's nation ? 

Nationalism is extreme patriotism, typically coupled with a sense that ones nation is superior to others



Around the Network

How is it going in the US with creationism vs evolution in schools? And didn't Trump call for teaching patriotism in schools as well? I already find it weird schools here in Canada start with the national anthem each morning. Then again, I never got brainwashed like that in the Netherlands and I moved out of there when I had the chance :)

Will we see a time when there's a worldwide school curriculum? Teaching kids about how the world works, contributed too by all countries. Schools can still teach local culture and history ofcourse.



"jihad as patriotic in spirit."

But that's not the true meaning of Jihad, like, at all.

So it's just another co-opting of a word for political control. Shouldn't really be surprised.

Turkey is devolving fast. I wonder if this would be happening if the EU had been more welcoming of Turkey as a member of the back before Erdogan started dismantling the secular bulwarks upon which modern Turkey was founded.



“The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell

"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."

Jimi Hendrix

 

binary solo said:

"jihad as patriotic in spirit."

But that's not the true meaning of Jihad, like, at all.

So it's just another co-opting of a word for political control. Shouldn't really be surprised.

Turkey is devolving fast. I wonder if this would be happening if the EU had been more welcoming of Turkey as a member of the back before Erdogan started dismantling the secular bulwarks upon which modern Turkey was founded.

What are you talking about? This is exactly the WRONG thing to do when this is happening. Plus, letting Turkey into the EU means that 80 million turks can now roam around EU nations with no border controls. Not only would it be a security risk, but there would be millions of turks flooding the labour market in other nations as well. It would be an absolute disaster.



Made a bet with LipeJJ and HylianYoshi that the XB1 will reach 30 million before Wii U reaches 15 million. Loser has to get avatar picked by winner for 6 months (or if I lose, either 6 months avatar control for both Lipe and Hylian, or my patrick avatar comes back forever).

There is a rise of the far-right at the moment.

This is just another example of that with Erdogan favoring conservative religion in the school curriculum.




www.youtube.com/@Pemalite

The True Meaning Of Jihad. Sounds like a South Park episode.



- "If you have the heart of a true winner, you can always get more pissed off than some other asshole."