Actually, this is the first post that makes you seem scummy to me... mainly because you seem that sure that prof is town when he seems a bit odd to me. I also don't agree with most of your scumlist. What makes you think Sword is town though? I am mainly curious on that because my opinion on sword is actually... absolutely neutral.

Don't worry, I didn't forget you.  I just saved the best for last!
-I was really impressed by hatmoza's big data contribution, and correspondingly I didn't think much of padib's reason for dismissing its value.  He said that his lack of interaction with players is due to the fact that he is "calm", which is just mind-boggling in and of itself.  Surely he meant some other thing because calmness has nothing to do with whether or not he interacts with other players in the game.  I called this out. 
-Then he went on the attack against hatmoza and said no one cared about his data. 
-Then he voted TruckOSaurus (pretty much out of nowhere, or so it seemed to me).  He suggested that we "trickle votes in", which made me suspicious that perhaps he was scum who didn't really care who got lynched but just wanted it to be whoever had enough support to accomplish the lynch. 
-Then, after prof voted him, he immediately revenge voted.  I mean if I had more respect for him as a player, I would be more hesitant to consider this a scum tell, but as it stands he's just some guy to me with a textbook scum tell. 

Basically, I completely agreed with prof, so I didn't articulate my own thoughts.  I should have said that much, at the very least.  Whoops. 

As for why I voted padib, it wasn't a dagger vote, I chose to trust hat's judgment and it turned out to be wrong. I still think he was looking for easy lynches, and wanted to 100% confirm that, and I did, and look now, he's completely changed his tone entirely and not haphazardly voting for "lurkers." He'll try to drive the tip of the knife home on anyone on his suspect list. He's flip flopping. I think he's working with only one other person, I don't think the possibility of one mafia are very likely. Instead, there is probably one town member (vig or not) who has the ability to day kill.

And again, I disagree with Hat. I don't think Spurge and Stefl are scum. I trust Sword as well. I do think Hat is scum however, because the way he's playing has been shady. He tried to push for lurker lynches, he got what he wanted and now he's trying to tie the noose around my neck due to my votes. Right now, HoS on him. He also didn't bother answering my question from day one and has casually jumped over it as if it was never there.