I'm inclined to believe Baalz.

This is also because he claimed Marie. I know character claims may be a stretch, however, Marie is a character where poetry is a primary character trait. I do not think he's playing us right now.

@Prof, interesting tactic, though we're only assuming an SK.

As others have said, that's a really bad reason to delay giving your information.  Just give it to us now, then we can talk about what that means for whether there is a vanilla townie in the game. 

If you were hoping to trap someone into claiming vanilla and then using your info against them, it was already a long shot in what is clearly a power heavy setup, and it's not worth the delay.  Fess up. 

I'm not suggesting to consider your scan as a lynch possibility toDay either. It should be considered if the game continues though.

Grasp of good balance is about roles. Between the flips and claims, town has many strong roles, many of which have some negative utility to them. Nothing is confirmed for mafia, but they may have an additional kill and with all of the PRs I would expect a Roleblocker though they didn't choose to block you.

For my reads, I'd say you, Arm, and Mr.P are all basically confirmed town for me. zero seems very much to be playing as he does when town. prof hasn't displayed his town not-mafia tell yet, and by this point in time I'd expect it to have shown up. I don't recall any scummy flags though, but he didn't explain his change in stance on Mr.P either. Trucks started off townish for me, but his level of enthusiasm has waned as of late. I know there's the excuse of the holidays, but I'm beginning to think he's grown tired of the charade.

#1 I'm gonna check Day One postals.

#2 Could be about Stefl, no?

#3 I'd agree that it is probably Trucks.

#1 Will check who name claimed before Night 2 as well. I don't think platina did.

#2 Again you mistyped Miz, instead of Noctis.

Is it possible for you to get the same person multiple Nights?

Are you suggesting platina or one of the other victims is actually a different role?(or even alignment) That does seem unlikely without some role to counter it, which Dreamer possibily could except Baalz says he only dreams of living players.

I find it odd that you'd have a cooldown on your ability though. I still think it's highly likely you are town, but such a limitation is pretty strange. The possibility of buffing mafia makes it risky, but it's not OP even if there's a confirmed townie for you to buff each Day either. 

prof is half right. I don't actually expect that there's a vig, so if there's another Night with two deaths, I would push for the claimer's lynch. But vig or SK, it would help decide who to lynch toDay regardless. There's a slight possibility that mafia used an extra kill to get us to MYLO, but I don't think a 4-man team with an extra kill would be good balance.

Now that Mr.P's claimed his ability was interfered with, it's definitely not a good idea for a vig to come forward if they have extra shots.

Even epicmafia describes the Killer as someone that shoots every night. So either mafia and the SK overlapped on spurge, or a kill was protected.

First, do you get exactly one poem about mafia each Night, or is it as axum said where it's at least one.(which matches the epicmafia description)

So you're against a mass-claim to try to figure out the liars?  I'm not sure it's a good idea myself but I want to hear a good reason to rule it out. 

Interesting enough look at it Linkz. But until Mr. P comes forth, I have not ruled him out. He WAS acting townish but this inability to let us know what's wrong is iffy. I will keep your deductions strongly in mind, however. I'm still waiting for his information.

If we're going to mass then yeah I think a vig should come clean rather then try to fakeclaim something else, but they don't have to be honest about their number of shots. As for whether we should or not, I think if Mr.P's information does not turn out to be a solid lead then it could be worth a shot. It's dangerous in the sense that mafia will likely easily dictate the Night, but we're only a mislynch or two away from losing.