I hit reset by accident so I will summarize.
I'm fine with lynching Noctis to get answers. His actions were suspicious.
@linkz, I have always suspected Noctis since Day 2 began, my stance hasn't changed. I got weary because he claimed miller, nothing more.
@zero, I ran a game where I had insane character as a role, there's your explanation of why I backed off. It is more questioning my own read.
Everyone is correct, Noctis could still be lying. Better to get answers than to pussyfoot around.
Vote: Noctis
I hope to YHVH that we're correct on this one.