By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Mafia Round 75 - Persona Theme - MAFIA VICTORY

NoCtiS_NoX on 27 December 2016
Linkzmax said:

Mafia usually assume there is a cop already, even if they don't have a Godfather. Claiming Day one means a cop won't waste a scan on you. Now , since that may have actually happened we are in the exact same boat of choosing to believe your role or not, as if you had claimed yesterDay. Not sure where the idea of a miller claiming after a cop claim to give them more credibility comes from, but claiming beforehand would do the same.

I understand that. It means I can vouch for him. I think we have a different view from that one. Also, if they can lynch me then it gives more credibilty with his claimed that's what I am thinking. 



Around the Network
Clyde32 on 27 December 2016

Votals

Put your votes on a separate line and in bold, if not in this format they will not be counted.

The day will end on December 29th at 7:00 PM EST. A vote for a time limit or time extension must be a 33% of the players' votes to pass.

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch. 

Player L6 L5 L4 L3 L2 L1 Lynch
platina stefl1504            
arminillo platina final-fan   Noctis_NoX        
zero129 baalzamon            
stefl1504 zero129            

 

History:

noctis votes mr. p
blade votes noctis
platina votes arminillo
final-fan votes arminillo
noctis unvotes
noctis votes arminillo
blade unvotes
baalz votes zero
stefl votes platina
zero votes stefl



NoCtiS_NoX on 27 December 2016
axumblade said:
NoCtiS_NoX said:

As I have mentioned lynch me then. I will flip town. If you want I can post my whole PM so I will be modkilled?

No. As of right now, I think Mr. P or Arm are who I am leaning more towards. I don't generally vote until I feel its right. I'm just untrusting of your claim. 

If you suspect them why are you not voting them to apply pressure so they will keep on talking?



NoCtiS_NoX on 27 December 2016
axumblade said:
NoCtiS_NoX said:

If you suspect them why are you not voting them to apply pressure so they will keep on talking?

Because I would rather not bandwagon on anybody unless I feel certain I am right. I realize a vote is just a vote. 

 

Also since I was wrong on day 1, I don't want to hastily vote on a user who might be telling the truth.

Correct me if I wrong are you questioning your scum list?



BladeSymphony on 27 December 2016

Yeah, I don't know why you guys are currently going for the ruse offense, I'm just very weary of lynching him currently. It could very well be a ruse on his part. It just makes sense that certain actions have caused me to make a misstep on Night 1, and making quick assumptions can lead to mislynches.

Noctis and Stefl are still high on my potential scum meter. I don't know whether to trust Noctis or not, his claim is rather convenient, and Stefl's claim heavily counters my various softclaims.



Steam ID: bladesym | Track of the Week (01/15/2017): Undertale - Megalovania

"You... are not human, are you?"
"Who knows? I'm not even sure myself."
Around the Network
TruckOSaurus on 27 December 2016

Back from my Christmas travels, prepare for another series of out of date comments.



Signature goes here!

TruckOSaurus on 27 December 2016
Linkzmax said:
TruckOSaurus said:

How quickly we wemt from mr p is scum for a fact to i think he 100% is not scum

Blade said Noctis is scum for a fact, and based on Noctis pushing for Mr.P, thinks Mr.P is not scum.

Ah that makes more sense... I knew there was a reason I usually never play Mafia from my phone.



Signature goes here!

TruckOSaurus on 27 December 2016
Arminillo said:
@linkzmax


Why is my speculation based on persona knowledge such a big problem? I admit I'm probably reading too much into it, but I don't think its worthless. Prof said he had a Hanged Man arcana, but has claimed a name that is Sun. I think that is something but no one cares.

Still, I will try to tone it down as people seem to hate it.

I think flavor hunting does have some value too but you can't put all your faith in just that.

About prof, what you're saying is that his claimed arcana and character don't match?



Signature goes here!

TruckOSaurus on 27 December 2016
Stefl1504 said:
Arminillo said:

So they both were targeted by different double vote enablers?

I believe Mr. P isn't aware that he peeked into my PM. The double vote enabler is the town role that targeted me.

So you would be the one with two votes and Mr. P would have seen that message (and thought it meant he had the double vote?) and also your message that you got no info? (Sorry if this was cleared up in later posts but I prefer commenting as a read).



Signature goes here!

TruckOSaurus on 27 December 2016
zero129 said:
Linkzmax said:

I said I don't think it is as weak as you seem to say it is. It's not particularly strong as I pointed out at one point, since I don't think he clarified wether his vote was for miz trying to get away with scummy behavior himself or just for allowing it. But he probably had the best reasoning after spurge for voting miz.

As for toDay, to start with he's not using the holiday as an excuse to go into lurking and is asking questions instead. Specifically his questioning me is something I don't think he'd do as scum since it draws my attention towards him.

No it was weak... I dont buy into the whole "Not as strong" etc mindframe. Trucks is a long time mafia player. He as town should not have been so willing to place such a weak vote. For me since trucks is such a long time player that makes his reason for voting even weaker then the newbs votes. I honestly dont know how your not seeing this...

The questions his asking today is nothing but fluff. Even his questioning to you was very weak.. And yes i do fully believe a mafia trucks would go after you since he would know you long enough to know it "Might" not make you so suspicious of him. Plus he didnt exactly go after you very strongly.

So you've gone into berserked zero mode where you see me as scum and therefore see everything I do as scummy to confirm your suspicions. My vote on Day one was on the person I honestly thought was the mostly likely to be scum, I don't consider it weak at all and to answer Linkz's questionning, I did believe his proposed attitude of waiting for power roles and not analyzing people's post was him being scum trying to play off his previous loss to justify a lack of effort to scumhunt.



Signature goes here!