How am i being relentless when i just said i was going to backoff on flavorhunting? I also dont like that term, its invaldative and i think i havent presented an illogical argument based on flavor all game.

On another note, its going to be very hard for me to defend myself or make large posts in the up coming days but i will try to at least read.

How likely do you think it is that scum would have an ability that lets them intercept and read messages given by the moderator to other players? 

Good point on the first part, but what is "invaldative" supposed to mean? 

It's not that your claims about the alignments of Persona characters are wrong, it's that those arguments have no known bearing on this game, except as a loose tie to the style of powers a player might have, if they have powers.  Even then, it's just a guessing game IMO as to what aspects of the character Clyde chose to intrepret into a mafia role, and how.  A guessing game that distracts and detracts from other discussion. 

It certainly seems but is there a reason a townee can't have the same ability?

If Mr. P is scum, and if by some miracle, Noctis is telling the truth, despite my claims of him being scum, then as I said, there's a particular scenario here where the puzzle pieces fit. It just involves role claiming, which I doubt anyone is willing to do. That's one scenario.

Another is Mr. P isn't scum and Noctis is lying through his teeth.

Care to explain how my particular statement is scummy? I'm not remotely following your logic.

If I got lynch I don't care because my role is really disruptive. Might as well lose me now than having doubts later on. 

But I want you guys look into MrP and Armi. That's all. I will be busy now.

As for Zero. Don't asked read between the lines. HoS on you by the way. 

I don't buy your commotion a while ago. 

I won't be able to respond as much now. I will be busy.

Since I also suspect Armi.

Might as well do this.

UNVOTE

VOTE: Arminillo

I fully admit I went with a gut feeling. It's day one. And I fully regret that. However, as of this point, I am actually hunting scum. Whether you believe I am town or not is your call. If you want to lose another town member, you can chase after me all you like.

Town vibes doesn't mean I think he's a townee at all. In fact as of this point my scum list looks very different from the info and softclaims Noctis has been giving me. In fact, if he's correct, the list looks more like this: Scum: Mr. P, Arminillo, Trucks, Stefl

Because his role seems to directly conflict with mine, I'm back at square one. Mafia is highly likely to attack one of us tonight, unless Noctis is lying through his teeth.

I'm beginning to think your role directly conflicts with mine. I can't be quite sure, but from the way you're phrasing it, that strongly seems like it would be the case. And if that's true...

I'm thinking the scum list would look a lot like this: Scum: Mr. P, Arminillo, Trucks, Stefl

But only if you're telling the truth, if not, then it's back square one, though I feel the mafia might be gunning for my head tonight considering my softclaims. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt.

Unvote Noctis