Sorry for late responses, I've been working long hours thus am stuck to my phone being only method still.


Couple of quick thoughts, I researched the name claim and nothing really stuck out as an obvious power role from it, but I'm by no means a Persona expert. Wouldn't surprise me if names aren't related to roles this game.

So much of the conversation has been pretty worthless so far imo, granted that is relatively usual on day 1. The top lynch prospects are by no means at the top of my list right now, so I have no issue going into night without a lynch. That being the case? Something seems significantly off to me about spurge. In particular, I've always gotten a scummy vibe from him (yet he was always town in those games). I can't pin it to any one comment of his this game, but something gives me a town vibe from him this game (which based on the above scummy vibe/town assumption, could mean townie vibe = scum). It is a far stretch, but I think it stands a heck of a lot better chance then those we have votes on right now.

Normally I'd follow this up with a barrage of 30 posts finding the flaws in everything he says to push for his vote, but that simply isn't possible on my phone, so this is really the extent of my powers and I just want my current vote/thoughts to be known.

Vote: Spurge

Big town read on Trucks btw.

I should clarify the vibe rule on spurge didn't apply to last game, but that is largely cause I was so locked onto Mr. P and was then murdered before I could analyze anybody else.

Don't ask why. Running an experiment here, interested if I can get town reads from more people for the same thing.

Fuuka Yamagishi in Persona 3 uses her power to locate the enemy and scan them for weaknesses, she also uses it to locate allies in the story, (but not as a gameplay function). I think she would be one of the most likely game candidates to have a power role. I understand that people dont want to out themselves as a power role, but lets not give people the wrong idea about the nature of this game. Clyde clearly likes Persona a lot, as Philemon is a pre-P3/P4 character, which are the "mainstream" entries in the franchise.

Which by that I mean Clyde would be inclined to know and pick characters for corresponding roles.

You're right.

That was a quite an interesting read.

I'm getting more and more town vibes from Trucks, on purpose or not, his demeanor has changed. I'll still be watching him. It's fishy how quickly the voters backed off of him, but I'd like my vote to count, and want to see a lynch.

Unvote Trucks

So I ask here:

miz, why shouldn't I vote for you? Why should I vote Stefl?
Stefl, why shouldn't I vote for you? Why should I vote miz?

If anyone else has input, let me know. I want to see a lynch, and I'm getting scum vibes from BOTH users right now.

I sincerely think there are mafia lurking who are throwing each other under the bus to save face as well. More than likely this is happening between those arguing in fact

Prof vs. Splurge
Stefl vs. miz

Etc.

Could be in cahoots and trying to say alive by blaming each other. We should consider this. Though it may not be, but the possibility should be left on the table.

Woops, Stefl voted zero, my mistake there. Same question applies however.

That chart is just confusing.

Okay, forget the questions, apologies. I wanted to hear some reasoning from the voters about past games but that might be asking for too much

My current scum list consists of: Stefl, miz, Spurge

Not sure about zero.

These are the people who have exhibited the oddest behavior.

votes miz

He has the most votes and I'm going with the my gut.