I am very sorry I am not putting up better arguments, but there is no steady argument I can make, it is like a deep unsettling feeling, a smell so much there for me, I need to act upon it.

Still catching up, worked a lot over the weekends and already almost 500 posts is very daunting.

Dude, what are you even tlaking about in this post? So it is some sort of shadow? Do you listen to yourself?

Maybe if you actually googled hanged man persona, you'd be able to have an informed decision, but posts like this just muddy the waters and add to this ridiculous post count of people calling out everyone for really minor infractions. Going through the thread there is so little going on, it bewilders me how there can be 500 posts about nothing.

Nothing to see here. Summary: everyone is accusing others of playing differently

Thoughts so far, much so much effort has been expounded on behalf of zero and spurge's ideas.
Blade seems really well informed, a lot of his thoughts have been things that I'm thinking. There's a slight nag at the back of my mind that he has too much insight, and it appears to me that he may be repeating things he's heard before. Though I also thought Linkz was suspicious his first game for having smart reads, and it turned out he was just experienced, so potentially a good player here with Blade, or potentially scum.
Arminillo is solid town.
MrP I'm very confident is town.

Yaknow, one good thing about having not been around for me personally is that I have a lot less emotion invested in my posts, which often clouds my judgement.

Trucks I'm not willing to lynch today, but day 2 he ranks probably as my highest lynch candidate. There's something off, and I really didn't like his comment to spurge about account switching.

Arm, you're new and you already have a better grasp of what's going on than most of our vets.

I'm reading through this like, people are accusing each other of semantics, and made-up meta. Changing playstyles is not a valid meta. It can literally mean anything. You guys said mrp was different last game, and he was, but he wasn't scum. And this game as well. 

The basic idea in mafia is to look at motive and action. Who did what, who pushed which way, what was the outcome, etc. So much and so little is being said in this thread that is makes everything really hard to analyze. 

My top candidates are stefl, trucks

Stefl should be obvious. His play today is 'intentionally different' and that doesn't sit well with me. I'm going to look back and see if he talks at all about playstyles. If someone is available to help, I'd appreciate it.

All the arcana are shadows at some point.

I don't know how you got shadow out of it, because I try googling it and I keep getting this link:
megamitensei.wikia.com/wiki/Hanged_Man_Arcana

Are you seriously going to use Axum's 3 more posts per day as different than usual? He didn't say he was acting different intentionally. He said he was trying to be more active because he keeps getting killed early.

And as for trucks, he only acknowledged your viewpoint that if he is playing different, it's because he's supposedly town.

Stefl is so clearly different from last game, it's almost a parody of itself, and he's the only one you haven't really mentioned aside from some posts that you think he's probably scum, and he should be played hard, but you haven't asked him any hard hitting questions.

Just to finish off this note as well, talking more or less is not playing different.
People's behavior is what qualifies as different.

And I know I'm usually the one who points at someone and says they seem to be playing different. It's giving me a very weird feeling watching you say it. And you've said it a lot. It's almost 40% of your contributions today.

Why, because shadows are bad in persona?

I'm not astounded. I'm frustrated and I'm probably displacing it onto you because I've wanted to read and participate but kept seeing 70 new posts, 51 new posts, 60 new posts and felt bad for not participating, and now upon reading, I'm mad at myself for not participating when most of today's discussion is blah. 

Perhaps I'm being overly judgemental of you. All I know is a felt bad for not participating, and now feel like I wasted my time on at least half of it.

Truck
O
Saurus