By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Mafia Round 75 - Persona Theme - MAFIA VICTORY

Linkzmax said:
miz1q2w3e said:

And name claimed so easily too. You really wanted to put this out there asap. Smells like mafia safe-claim if you ask me. Remember last game, and how easily prof wanted his made up narrative out there asap? I'm getting the same feeling here.

While I agree with you on the PR soft claim feeling like the soft claim as mafia last round, I don't see any issue with the name claim. If mafia have safe claims then they're designed to blend in with town names. Why do you think a townie wouldn't want to name claim?

I dunno. I just feel like a townie would want to keep everything hidden until the right moment. Whereas someone who wants to push a narrative would want to get the info out there asap. That was why prof's claim last game felt so scummy to me.



Around the Network
TruckOSaurus said:
miz1q2w3e said:

I know my style has changed, but I can't help it. I just don't see much value in questioning people over random observations or feelings anymore. Power roles exist for a reason. I was on the fence last game regarding this debate, but now I've made up my mind.

So you wanna play follow the cop? That also amounts to saying a vanilla townie is useless which is not the case. Last game, the power roles didn't get any info of value. Questionning people about their motivations and making observations about links between players is the most important thing in the game. That and voting for scummy people.

A big fat LOL to that. I completely disagree. People can lie, and text interactions make it that much easier. Vanilla townies' job is to be as town-y as possible, and pay attention to info so that they can vote with PRs. By the way, I'm still mad about not having any good enough power roles last game to combat scum (in my opinion).

So yeah, I wanna see these motivation questioning and observation skills you're talking about. So far you're chasing after zero for shit reasons one second, and the next you decided joined a near baseless bandwagon on me... but no no, you got this bro. I'm all ears.



spurgeonryan said:
vote : Miz

Ugh, now what? Why are you voting for me?



spurgeonryan said:
Ugh....why did you even quote me?

Why are you voting for me?



spurgeonryan said:
You have no idea why I would even dare vote you?^

Nope, I'm dumb. Enlighten me, please.

Why are you voting for me?



Around the Network
spurgeonryan said:
Just stick with me, look at it from a town's point of view and you definitely being scum.

Let's see what you can find.

I'm not letting this go unanswered. I can't answer on your behalf either, since I'm not scum.

Why are you voting for me?



miz1q2w3e said:
TruckOSaurus said:

So you wanna play follow the cop? That also amounts to saying a vanilla townie is useless which is not the case. Last game, the power roles didn't get any info of value. Questionning people about their motivations and making observations about links between players is the most important thing in the game. That and voting for scummy people.

A big fat LOL to that. I completely disagree. People can lie, and text interactions make it that much easier. Vanilla townies' job is to be as town-y as possible, and pay attention to info so that they can vote with PRs. By the way, I'm still mad about not having any good enough power roles last game to combat scum (in my opinion).

So yeah, I wanna see these motivation questioning and observation skills you're talking about. So far you're chasing after zero for shit reasons one second, and the next you decided joined a near baseless bandwagon on me... but no no, you got this bro. I'm all ears.

That's the whole point of the game. Figuring out who's lying and who's really honest with the occasional boost from information coming from a PR.

I'll grant you that I might have stuck to zero a little too long but I've shared my thoughts about Stefl, Noctis, Mr. Playstation and you. I'll continue to do so as the Day unfolds, I might be far off, I might be right on the money but at least I'm contributing.



Signature goes here!

spurgeonryan said:
But you cannot name any reasons?
Maybe that is reason enough.

Of course I can give my own reasons, but that would be answering the question for you.

But fine, don't answer. The reason I pushed is to make it clear to townies who are paying attention that you have no case.



TruckOSaurus said:

That's the whole point of the game. Figuring out who's lying and who's really honest with the occasional boost from information coming from a PR.

I'll grant you that I might have stuck to zero a little too long but I've shared my thoughts about Stefl, Noctis, Mr. Playstation and you. I'll continue to do so as the Day unfolds, I might be far off, I might be right on the money but at least I'm contributing.

Again, I disagree. Now, is a mere disagreement worth lynching over?

You know what, though? I realized your argument doesn't necessarily have to make logical sense... if you're scum. Quick to bandwagon using Stefl's vote as the start, flipping from Zero to me so easily with vague half-assed reasoning.

Yeah, you're scum. I don't blame spurge for thinking I'm scummy, since it's true that I was lurking earlier (I know that's the reason he's after me, even though he won't say it for some reason). If you had just said that, then I'd be less inclined to think you're scum, but your attempt to make a case out of nothing, just to join the BW, is scummy af.

Vote: Trucks

I still think Stefl is scummy, but tbh one thing that bugs me is that scum rarely start BWs on their own. Yours is classic scum behavior, though.



spurgeonryan said:
I just actually gave you a reason. That you did not answer.

So I guess we both refuse to answer more or less.

What does that mean?

Are you kidding me? I asked you a sincere question to try and get your thoughts, and you reply with another question. How is that scummy on my part???

spurgeonryan said:
Also there are really no cases on day one. I believe you have said this same thing either last game or this game. Probably was last game. Did you want a lynch day one last game Miz?

I was on the fence, but given that it got us nowhere, I don't have that opinion anymore.