I wasn't asking about the Mr.P thinkg, but since you bring it up.
Stefl1504 said:
miz1q2w3e said:
Welp, I guess I'm caught up, though it doesn't feel like it. I dunno, I didn't really get many strong reads, but fuck it I'll post em anyway: - Town: Arminillo, Zero, BladeSymphony, Noctis (unfortunately, he's playing the same as last game). - Maf: I guess Stefl and prof maybe.
I heavily agree with Platina's portion of the post here; Stefl unintentionally implied (both in wording, and logic) that they are on opposite teams. Also, Stefl doesn't really care if Mr.P is inno, and want to lynch him regardless. Sound familiar?
|
@bold, no I implied that whoever he is on a team with will lose because of him, if I am scum and I know he is a townie why the fuck would I ever want to lynch him? From my point of view that would be destructive (doesn't change that I am still mad about his playstyle last game tho) With all he did so far in this day he is proving me wrong, I am fine with him overall if he keeps playing like this (he contributed more in like 2-3 posts this game than he did in all of last game).
I use his/our/their/my/your very carefully in comparison to the town/scum, it is the easiest way to manipulate people verbally. With 3 people left using our over the town is basically a gold mine, hell it even can be with 5 left. his/her team is really powerful when you don't know their allignment and should not be used as scum unless you already successfully painted someone as scum, just because people will stumble in the logical falacy that you imply team segregation unintentionally, it can also be a very powerful spell cast on a team-mate when you are about to be lynched anyway.
|
Why would you as scum want to lynch him? You don't want another empty victory. You want people thinking you can't be scum again if you pushed his mislynch instead of using him for another win.
Similarly, the rest is WIFOM. Here's what you said about Mr.P's alignment. This only describes how he played one time, as town. And here's what you said when Trucks asked about other games. Still implying you aren't concerned about him being mafia nor giving any credit to his mafia play. Though when you gave him the MVP award in Round 73 you did say "no real reason," so maybe you thought that he had it easy?(yes zero lost that game for town, but I'd say Mr.P played great even if mafia had lost)
As I said early on, your vote for Mr.P would be a good way to get the same behavior from him if he's town again and that's how you truly expect him to play when he's town. You gave him no chance to be productive without any pressure. Then when he didn't play exactly the same way, you expectedly unvoted him, but also have a slight town read on him. He's not being useless town; therefore, he's town? It's like you're still not considering that he could be playing differently because he's scum.
I would say you did all of this knowing he's town the whole time and trying to play up your saltiness as town since you saw Trucks do the same, but I'm leaning scummates due to his weak reasoning for calling you town.