By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Mafia Round 75 - Persona Theme - MAFIA VICTORY

spurgeonryan said:
So Mr. P who is on your small scum list so far.

Who are you scumlist Spurge?

So far mine is one of the new player in here. Armadinillo and the other one is miz. 



Around the Network
NoCtiS_NoX said:
Mr.Playstation said:

No, why should I stop quoting you. In fact I'm going to quote you more.

What do you expect him to tell you? "Oh I'm mafia, I'm going to kill you tonight *Evil Laugh*.

You've gone from this;

I might need to reread the whole thread again. I got confused on whats happening.

to this

You tell me spurge? Who are your scummates?

to this
How many are you? (Asking Armadinillo)

to see the above question.

Your whole vibe throughout the whole thread has just being negative, especially when asked questions;

Didn't I explain it already? http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8201812

Why are you so fixated with this? 

Did you already answer my question?

Can any veterans confirm if there are any town roles who already have an idea of who they should question during the day. Like for example Clyde would have sent Noctis a hint that by questioning Arminillo/Spurge he may get some answers on who's scum? Are town even allowed to know anything about anyone else before night one?

Otherwise these questions from Noctis are really just filler. Being so blatant when it comes to scum hunting won't get us anywhere.

1. I am fishing for reactions. I am not expecting that he will tell me everything or slip. I want to see his reactions. It's day 1 for crying out loud. Any question will lead into a conversation. The same for spurge. Look how he ignore it. 

2. Yes I am confused because there was a lot of votes flying around. I am not sure if it's a joke votes or a seriouse votes.

What's troubling is you keep on quoting me before this people can answer.

Well you're doing a poor job at fishing for reactions and no not all questions will lead into a conversation, especially when there as one dimensional as yours. If let's say Arminillo reacts angry it could be for one of two reasons;

1) He's scum who's been caught

2) He's town who's angry at the fact that someone is calling him scum.

If Arminillo reacts calmly to your question;

1) He's a scum who's lying

2) He's town who's being reasonable.

Not sure exactly what you'll get out of these reactions. 

Spurge had every right to skip your question (Not defending Spurge), 'cause it was seriously just a poor question.



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Arminillo said:
NoCtiS_NoX said:

Who are you going to kill tonight?

Mr. Morooka

I'm assuming you've heard of quicktopic, right?



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

NoCtiS_NoX said:
BladeSymphony said:

If I were to guess the number, I'd say 3 or 4 scum and possibly one more third-party seems plausible for a game of this size. I'm not sure if the third-party is an SK, but is probably a neutral role that helps neither mafia or town. Jester, Serial Killer, Lovers might be plausible for this theme.

Clyde invited me 2 years ago when I was part of IGN to join the forum itself. I just stuck around there and played and hosted mafia games on IGN since I was already an established moderator there for the front page, but because of no shows, I wanted to play a more active game, so he recently invited me to this one. I am already liking the activity far more.

Mr. P seems to have thrown his team under the bus last game but that doesn't mean he will do so again here. He's put up a small defense for Stefl and said that anyone voting for zero is suspicious. I have made note of that in case any info on any of them turns up, I would throw more suspicion on him then, but for now I don't have any definitive read on him as either town or scum.

Splurge is providing good reasoning and has said we're getting ahead of ourselves a couple times already, yet he was one of the first to throw shade, first at Trucks and then at Zero. I agree with zero that those who change their minds easily have a higher chance of being scum. That's one iffy play.

I think Arminillo's slip up might point out that he has a role, he said he wants to see how night works, which immediately points out that he may have some sort of PR, whether mafia or town.

The idea that Trucks doesn't like playing mafia could be a reason for him playing disinterestedly but then again he could be the SK, playing distantly on purpose so no one suspects him, but didn't expect that his change in play would be noticed by anyone here. That's just my take on it however, my vote stays on him as he was the first to throw down.

As for other members, Stefl not knowing how to play his role and being so vocal might confirm he's town, but I'm reaching here. I have no read on Linkz. He's playing quite neutrally.

That would be my take thus far.

So if you are going to vote who do you think will be the best candidate?

I've casted a vote for Trucks because he was the first one to throw shade. After that I'd probably vote for Arminillo, but that's on the grounds that he actually has played the game before and understands the rules. Right now he's either play acting or just doesn't know what's going on. I get town vibes from Stefl, I don't think scum would act out so early and reveal he has a PR. In fact, there's a high chance scum will kill him tonight knowing this.

axumblade said:
BladeSymphony said:
Mr. P is being very defensive of several players. Should probably keep an eye on that, from Stefl, Zero, to quoting Noctis on Arminillo.

Combining Arminillo's slip up with that defensive there -- big HoS on him. If Arminillo or Mr. P are scum, might be a strong chance the other one is too.

There is a lot of residual hostility from the last game in regards to mr. P. Seems to be the case for a lot of the way people in this game are choosing to focus.

That could explain it. The hostile vibes towards both Mr. P and Zero are pretty high. Since we don't have information, who knows if they could be scum or town, so I'm not sure what to think. I'm just throwing it out there, as a chance, just in case.

Mr.Playstation said:
BladeSymphony said:
Mr. P is being very defensive of several players. Should probably keep an eye on that, from Stefl, Zero, to quoting Noctis on Arminillo.

Combining Arminillo's slip up with that defensive there -- big HoS on him. If Arminillo or Mr. P are scum, might be a strong chance the other one is too.

I'm not really defensive of Arminillo, just questioning Noctis's rather blatant scum hunting questions. A better strategy to catch Arminillo in more slips is to disguise the questions.

Maybe Noctis is directing questions to push suspicion onto others so people don't get suspicious of him. Could be something to look out for, since he's on your scum list. I'm still unsure, but his questions seem rather blatant and deliberate.



Steam ID: bladesym | Track of the Week (01/15/2017): Undertale - Megalovania

"You... are not human, are you?"
"Who knows? I'm not even sure myself."

I havent played mafia online before, i lve only played an apparently extremely rudimentary version at a camp in middle school.

I dont know what quicktopic is.

I dont really want to read all the roles on the site but i guess i will get around to it.

I joined this game because of the persona theme, but i didnt realize how superficial the theme would be, and i probably shouldve looked at an earlier one u guys did because most of this is beyond me.

I voted truck because i thought we had to vote and didnt know that i would have more than one irl day to decide who to vote for.



Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda!!!!


Around the Network
zero129 said:
TruckOSaurus said:

Where exactly did you get this "easy lynch" idea from? You're the most stubborn person I know, you have an overinflated ego, you instantly deduce that anyone attacking you is scum and then proceed to see everything they do as scummy, you pretty much see your theories as facts and you have to ability to write annoyingly long posts when provoked. That doesn't amount to an easy lynch at all.

Isnt that my point?. If mafia think they will have an easy time coming after me they wont. Just like you say cos it will just make me bring them out in the open and at some point they will make a slip..

First , you say I'm scum trying for an easy lynch and now when I point out to you, you're anything but an easy lynch, suddenly you say that that's your point. So by your rationale, I can't be scum looking for an easy lynch, no?

BladeSymphony said:

If I were to guess the number, I'd say 3 or 4 scum and possibly one more third-party seems plausible for a game of this size. I'm not sure if the third-party is an SK, but is probably a neutral role that helps neither mafia or town. Jester, Serial Killer, Lovers might be plausible for this theme.

theprof00 said:
Blade, I notice you only have 9 posts to your name in 2 years.
What made you decide to play now?

Clyde invited me 2 years ago when I was part of IGN to join the forum itself. I just stuck around there and played and hosted mafia games on IGN since I was already an established moderator there for the front page, but because of no shows, I wanted to play a more active game, so he recently invited me to this one. I am already liking the activity far more.

NoCtiS_NoX said:

So now what. What do you think of  Spurge and Mr P?

Mr. P seems to have thrown his team under the bus last game but that doesn't mean he will do so again here. He's put up a small defense for Stefl and said that anyone voting for zero is suspicious. I have made note of that in case any info on any of them turns up, I would throw more suspicion on him then, but for now I don't have any definitive read on him as either town or scum.

Splurge is providing good reasoning and has said we're getting ahead of ourselves a couple times already, yet he was one of the first to throw shade, first at Trucks and then at Zero. I agree with zero that those who change their minds easily have a higher chance of being scum. That's one iffy play.

I think Arminillo's slip up might point out that he has a role, he said he wants to see how night works, which immediately points out that he may have some sort of PR, whether mafia or town.

The idea that Trucks doesn't like playing mafia could be a reason for him playing disinterestedly but then again he could be the SK, playing distantly on purpose so no one suspects him, but didn't expect that his change in play would be noticed by anyone here. That's just my take on it however, my vote stays on him as he was the first to throw down.

As for other members, Stefl not knowing how to play his role and being so vocal might confirm he's town, but I'm reaching here. I have no read on Linkz. He's playing quite neutrally.

That would be my take thus far.

Why is being the first to throw shade a bad thing? Yes, I voted early and without much other than a distaste for zero's playstyle but over any role townies can have, the strongest weapon we have to find scum is our votes. I believe your attitude toward my vote will make other townies reluctant to vote and that's exactly what scum wants. 



Signature goes here!

Also here's some reading music for everyone



Steam ID: bladesym | Track of the Week (01/15/2017): Undertale - Megalovania

"You... are not human, are you?"
"Who knows? I'm not even sure myself."
Arminillo said:
I havent played mafia online before, i lve only played an apparently extremely rudimentary version at a camp in middle school.

I dont know what quicktopic is.

I dont really want to read all the roles on the site but i guess i will get around to it.

I joined this game because of the persona theme, but i didnt realize how superficial the theme would be, and i probably shouldve looked at an earlier one u guys did because most of this is beyond me.

I voted truck because i thought we had to vote and didnt know that i would have more than one irl day to decide who to vote for.

You sure? All town people should have a quicktopic link in the e-mail Clyde sent us.



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Mr.Playstation said:
Arminillo said:
I havent played mafia online before, i lve only played an apparently extremely rudimentary version at a camp in middle school.

I dont know what quicktopic is.

I dont really want to read all the roles on the site but i guess i will get around to it.

I joined this game because of the persona theme, but i didnt realize how superficial the theme would be, and i probably shouldve looked at an earlier one u guys did because most of this is beyond me.

I voted truck because i thought we had to vote and didnt know that i would have more than one irl day to decide who to vote for.

You sure? All town people should have a quicktopic link in the e-mail Clyde sent us.

Should i PM him?



Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda!!!!


wait i havent checked my email i didnt know i was supposed to.



Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda Muda!!!!