Your vote actually works with some of what I have been thinking. I don't know how much rereading the previous Day helped directly, but indirectly I think it let me take a step back and find a new perspective. So I decided to type out literally every pair of mafia I could imagine you four making, with the required circumstances as I recall them:
Linkz as scum:
with arminillo who is a mafia Jack; one shot of double vote, used on town for townie points, and a block on axumblade that Linkz claimed to claim blocker; Linkz is redirector.
with Baalz who is ... mafia dreamer get the fuck out of here
with Mr.P who is mafia informant/journalist, and Linkz has at least one block shot in addition to being redirector
Mr.P as scum:
with Baalz who is mafia redirector; Mr.P is informant and covering for Baalz
with arminillo who is a mafia redirector who also had a one shot vote enhancement
(Linkz)
Baalz as scum:
(with Mr.P) anything else requires a mafia dreamer, which I refuse to believe
arminillo as scum:
(Linkz)
(Mr.P)
Of those, the ones I think are "relatively reasonable" include you with arminillo, Mr.P with Baalz, and Mr.P with arminillo. However, the "you and arminillo" one requires a mafia Jack of All Trades, and I note that Jack of any kind is practically nonexistent on the epicmafia site. Maybe that's going too far outside the game, but there it is. The only one that doesn't involve either a mafia Jack or "bonus" one-shots is Mr.P plus Baalz.
I will go back and check some of their earlier posts when I can. (Circumstances of Baalz claim, Mr.P, etc.)