Blade, I notice you only have 9 posts to your name in 2 years.
What made you decide to play now?

I'd say he's referencing my lack of enthusiasm when I draw the scum card.

1. Well I'll give you that playing better than my last game isn't quite hard to achieve so if I had been scum this time around, yes I would have probably done better than last game.
2. I'm not sure I've played "like this" before either but I don't believe I have a set style of play. I'm coming off a game as (disinterested) scum and a game as a host, now I'm Town.  These circumstances influence the way I'm playing now.

Where exactly did you get this "easy lynch" idea from? You're the most stubborn person I know, you have an overinflated ego, you instantly deduce that anyone attacking you is scum and then proceed to see everything they do as scummy, you pretty much see your theories as facts and you have to ability to write annoyingly long posts when provoked. That doesn't amount to an easy lynch at all.

3.  It wasn't because of you going after your voters that I made that statement; it was how you were incredibly careless, double quoting one guy at another's expense and double voting the guy you forgot to quote while not voting the guy you double quoted!  I can't even imagine being this careless in a game myself, regardless of alignment; so, after thinking about it, I can't really say that informs my view of you as potential scum until I get a better handle on your baseline level of crazy. 

Later on, as Linkz pointed out, you falsely claimed credit for the Mr.P mislynch, but that wasn't the sort of thing I was thinking of when I wrote the statement you quoted, as can be inferred from the fact that I was referring to the "initial votes" and not the later discussion in that sentence. 

4.  Remind me again, what "reply to mr.p" are you talking about?  I can't quite spot it, only a comment directed at him in a reply to ME:  "Mr.P make sure you do take notes. Cos what Final fan is telling me to do here "IS" what got you lynched last game." 

And regardless of what you may or may not have said to Mr.P, the question remains:  what did I, Final-Fan, tell you, zero129, to do, that "IS" what got Mr.P lynched last game? 

I'm not going to let this go unanswered. 

Who brought this to your attention? Fair warning: I predict you will respond with the name of a specific person, and I'll have a couple of follow-ups if/when you do.

Do you think Stefl shouldn't roleclaim, and if so why not?

There are some similarities in newbness, but arminillo directly answered your question and proposed a strategy that could help town.(though as was pointed out, would likely benefit mafia far more) He also voted Trucks right out the gate while darwin hid behind being cautious.

Well, he was throwing around the term and it didn't really make sense to me with my understanding of the term.  So the obvious solution is to define our terms and see what he is actually trying to say, and given that we are in a game of Mafia I decided to ask him to give the definition he was using before telling him mine.  Technically, therefore, I didn't know the answer, because I wanted HIS definition. 

As it turns out, he appears to be using the term to refer exclusively to a subset of what I would consider the term to apply to.  Either that, or he actually agrees with me but forgot to give the full definition because he was thinking about this specific case.  In your case, that is a sad policy, but can potentially count as a policy for policy lynching; but only IMO if you have a "tier list" of Day 1 lynchees, consisting of at least one player, and zero is the highest one on that list currently playing.  Modifiable based on lynchability, of course. 

Agreed. While we don't know the extent of his outside experience, he's showing fair logic already. Bonus props if he's scum and keeps up act.

I take this to mean Stefl is already prepared to claim. Mayhaps Stefl wants more people to vote him before he reveals, but I see nothing wrong with wanting him to claim as I am interested myself. It was a mistake last game to let Stefl off with just a softclaim of a PR.