I agree.

I'm just hoping mafia and sk kill each other at night. Axum is my other guess.

About fighting in winter:
Nevermind I had it wrong and posted spoilers so I deleted it but here is what it actually is:

Near the end of P4 If you get the secret adachi dungeon (our noctis' character), and then do a series of questions correctly, then you unlock a special dungeon that is only available during december and once you beat it, it skips to december 31st. 

Well, might as well put it out there. The first stone poem also hints at that character being a serial killer or vigilante.

I believe prof's sibling claim (although this doesnt mean he is town or mafia), so I don't think the first stone has anything to do with him.

Honestly at this point I feel like all my stupid ass poems have done is confuse both me and the town even further

Oh, actually it was spurge that was adachi. Guess my theory doesn't quite add up.
haha, I forgot why adachi got that role. That's actually really clever.

Won't be at all surprised to find out at the end that I misinterpreted every single poem.

I really need to focus on work the remainder of today, will hopefully have time this evening for more discussion

Arm was the first hammer maybe.
You got this poem night one right?
I'm confused though, you thought trucks was this role but said that it hinted at vig or serial killer?

Why would you say he's town?
Why on earth would you say this:
Zero, your claim makes absolutely no sense. Far too many investigative roles, and the game could nearly have been over for mafia after 1 night already. Also, why on EARTH would you claim you have a commuter role remaining. If town is truly this close to losing, wouldn't you want to hide this in hopes that mafia miss a kill on you? Finally, you seem to want to convince town to no end that Trucks is a Godfather when I'm led to believe something...ENTIRELY DIFFERENT. Don't worry Trucks, I won't tattle.

I said that because I thought that poem very specifically referred to trucks being a vigilante or serial killer, and I think it is in town's best interest to not have that role outed yet.

However, Trucks came out and claimed doctor, so we either have a lying trucks, we have no clue who the poem is about, or we are completely misinterpreting what the hell the poem even means.

what does the part about vig or sk say?

That he is wrong to peers, but thinks himself to be right.

It screams of a vigilante imo. Many people don't necessarily agree with a vigilante's ways, but they obviously think that what they are doing is for the good of all.