By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Mafia Round 74 -Overwatch Theme

Darwinianevolution No Lynch -- No Vote --          
Final-Fan Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
Linkzmax Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
miz1q2w3e Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
Mr.Playstation No Lynch Clyde32          
Noctis_NoX No Lynch  -- No Vote --          
spurgeonryan zero129 No Lynch -- No Vote --          
Stefl1504 Mr. Playstation Clyde32

Here's the full table of who's alive and what votes were placed by each person.

Noctis and Darwin have never managed to make up their minds on anything, care to explain?



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Around the Network
NoCtiS_NoX said:
Mr.Playstation said:

Yes, yes I am aware. I saw that FF had unvoted but then I didn't count his vote against Clyde. It's a stupid mistake, though by all means not the end of the world when Clyde was going to get lynched either way. Atleast it meant that for once we made up our mind on who to lynch.

 

If you don't believe that I'm a bullet proof role by now ( 1 shot bullet proof btw ), not even a screenshot of my message will make you believe me.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8186110

How can you missed that? 

I am asking a question for Darwin. The vote could have swayed both Darwin and Clyde is a candidate for a lynch.

Are you asking me a question?



You know it deserves the GOTY.

Come join The 2018 Obscure Game Monthly Review Thread.

Mr.Playstation said:
Darwinianevolution No Lynch -- No Vote --          
Final-Fan Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
Linkzmax Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
miz1q2w3e Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
Mr.Playstation No Lynch Clyde32          
Noctis_NoX No Lynch  -- No Vote --          
spurgeonryan zero129 No Lynch -- No Vote --          
Stefl1504 Mr. Playstation Clyde32

Here's the full table of who's alive and what votes were placed by each person.

Noctis and Darwin have never managed to make up their minds on anything, care to explain?

Are you asking me why I couldn't answer before the time ran out? The first time I wanted to see more the behaviour of the players here, so I voted a no lynch. I thought that it would give me more info about who might be mafia or not. The second time I had my suspicions mostly on prof, but he telling us that he had been targeted by mafia caught me off guard, and you voting yourself when I thought you were innocent was also pretty distracting. I was deciding whether or not to vote for you instead of anyone else when the time ran out and Clyde got killed. And now we are on a very dangerous position: we are eight players, with possibly 4 being mafia. The most active players have been targeted and taken down, just like I said on a previous post.

Honestly, now I'm somewhat suspicious of you, Mr.P. Now I have my doubts of whether that stunt (voting yourself) was to distract us and make yourself look innocend and tired of the game or not.



You know it deserves the GOTY.

Come join The 2018 Obscure Game Monthly Review Thread.

Darwinianevolution said:
Mr.Playstation said:
Darwinianevolution No Lynch -- No Vote --          
Final-Fan Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
Linkzmax Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
miz1q2w3e Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
Mr.Playstation No Lynch Clyde32          
Noctis_NoX No Lynch  -- No Vote --          
spurgeonryan zero129 No Lynch -- No Vote --          
Stefl1504 Mr. Playstation Clyde32

Here's the full table of who's alive and what votes were placed by each person.

Noctis and Darwin have never managed to make up their minds on anything, care to explain?

Are you asking me why I couldn't answer before the time ran out? The first time I wanted to see more the behaviour of the players here, so I voted a no lynch. I thought that it would give me more info about who might be mafia or not. The second time I had my suspicions mostly on prof, but he telling us that he had been targeted by mafia caught me off guard, and you voting yourself when I thought you were innocent was also pretty distracting. I was deciding whether or not to vote for you instead of anyone else when the time ran out and Clyde got killed. And now we are on a very dangerous position: we are eight players, with possibly 4 being mafia. The most active players have been targeted and taken down, just like I said on a previous post.

Honestly, now I'm somewhat suspicious of you, Mr.P. Now I have my doubts of whether that stunt (voting yourself) was to distract us and make yourself look innocend and tired of the game or not.

I still don't understand why you didn't vote for Clyde, since you yourself was the other lynch candidate. To me that shows not only a lack of inactivity ( If you were aware that the game was ending soon and that you might not make, then you should have voted asap) but you don't even want to stir town in the possible right direction ( Assuming you're town)

Going of my second point, do you yourself even believe that you're town?



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Mr.Playstation said:
Darwinianevolution said:

Are you asking me why I couldn't answer before the time ran out? The first time I wanted to see more the behaviour of the players here, so I voted a no lynch. I thought that it would give me more info about who might be mafia or not. The second time I had my suspicions mostly on prof, but he telling us that he had been targeted by mafia caught me off guard, and you voting yourself when I thought you were innocent was also pretty distracting. I was deciding whether or not to vote for you instead of anyone else when the time ran out and Clyde got killed. And now we are on a very dangerous position: we are eight players, with possibly 4 being mafia. The most active players have been targeted and taken down, just like I said on a previous post.

Honestly, now I'm somewhat suspicious of you, Mr.P. Now I have my doubts of whether that stunt (voting yourself) was to distract us and make yourself look innocend and tired of the game or not.

I still don't understand why you didn't vote for Clyde, since you yourself was the other lynch candidate. To me that shows not only a lack of inactivity ( If you were aware that the game was ending soon and that you might not make, then you should have voted asap) but you don't even want to stir town in the possible right direction ( Assuming you're town)

Going of my second point, do you yourself even believe that you're town?

I know I'm town. And why I didn't vote for Clyde, I had my suspicions that he was town (and, in hindsight, those suspicions were correct).



You know it deserves the GOTY.

Come join The 2018 Obscure Game Monthly Review Thread.

Around the Network
Mr.Playstation said:
Darwinianevolution No Lynch -- No Vote --          
Final-Fan Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
Linkzmax Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
miz1q2w3e Mr. Playstation Clyde32          
Mr.Playstation No Lynch Clyde32          
Noctis_NoX No Lynch  -- No Vote --          
spurgeonryan zero129 No Lynch -- No Vote --          
Stefl1504 Mr. Playstation Clyde32

Here's the full table of who's alive and what votes were placed by each person.

Noctis and Darwin have never managed to make up their minds on anything, care to explain?

Please do your history check and I have voted for clyde but to allow some time for him to explain I remove my vote because he is at L-1 to avoid him being lynched prematurely. You are gasping at straws here.



Darwinianevolution said:

I know I'm town. And why I didn't vote for Clyde, I had my suspicions that he was town (and, in hindsight, those suspicions were correct).

Can you please provide me your scum list and why?



Final-Fan said:
Linkzmax said:
I don't think No Lynch is a good choice at this point. We've had two Nights for any investigative roles to gather information, so at this point they either have it or there's a good chance they will be dead before they can share what they know if you and Stefl are right that there is no doc.

The alternative is another flip could be helpful in determining the setup, but I see two problems with that as well. 1) That would also help mafia if they need to fakeclaim and 2) If there's going to be a massclaim, then it should happen toDay as there will be more townies alive to weigh in on all the claims. For the record, I don't think a massclaim is a great idea either, seeing as no mafia are dead yet, and thus they're quite likely to be able to take advantage of us once everything is out in the open.

Sorry, Linkz, you lost town points here.  Even if you discount any possibility of gaining information or messing with mafia with town night actions, there's still a very solid reason to wait a day:  reducing the suspect pool. 

Assuming a 3 member mafia, the town needs a unanimous lynch to hit mafia, assuming no strategic mafia defection occurs.  If we No Lynch, tomorrow we will also need a unanimous lynch.  It's exactly the same difficulty level from that perspective.  However, each of us is also faced with 7 potential suspects, while tomorrow there will be 6. 

Hoepfully we can do better than pure random odds, but the base random-odds value improves if we No Lynch and that just has to improve our real chances, doesn't it? 

I've been in this position before, both on the winning and losing side. I'd rather hear from 4 other townies even if I can't be sure of their alignment over an even split in the unknowns. There's also a slight benefit in the fact that one wrong vote does not mean a quicklynch.

And despite your and Stefl's thoughts on the matter, I'm quite confident there is a doctor, which could sway numbers into town's favor.



Mr.Playstation said:

If you don't believe that I'm a bullet proof role by now ( 1 shot bullet proof btw ), not even a screenshot of my message will make you believe me.

This is pretty much without question at this point. Your alignment is still very much up in the air though.



Darwinianevolution said:

And now we are on a very dangerous position: we are eight players, with possibly 4 being mafia. The most active players have been targeted and taken down, just like I said on a previous post.

What was the winning condition for mafia in your IRL games?

The only active player that was taken down was prof, and his activity was waning Day Two. Do you not consider me active?