Ok so we have a lot of "this is the best game or this isone of the best games ever made" Maybe the game is indeed one of the best games ever, but your opinion is very different and that's ok...

I'm first, of course... mine is... Shadow of the colossus, I understand why people love the game, but imho the game is not that good. Besides the climbing mechanic, the gameplay is subpart, the soundtrack was good and the "story"?? is intriguing??? if you do some research I guess.

 Maybe because I played the game a year ago, same thing happends with a lot of people that play ocarina of time now, they say "the game is not that good and not even the best zelda game" because they play the game 18 years later and they don't see the wow factor. But I'm not sure about my "I played the game too late" opinion because a game like Cave Story is one of the best games ever made for me. 

I understand that shadows of the colossus is all about emotion when you're figthing the bosses and exploring the landscapes, and I won't lie, it's super emotional and artistic but for me is not enough to say "one of the best games ever"

I hated The Last of Us so much, I never even played it.

devil's third is atrocious and i'm disappointed with Itagaki-san. Who considers that game the best game ever tho?

I thought the game was overrated, then I played the game and now I think it's one of the best thrillers in gaming right there with Alan Wake. 

I can't stand Zelda Wind Waker, played it many years ago and found it very boring. I couldn't get behind the silent world and how ugly the characters were. I couldnttget into the combat either, and listening to Link drives me nuts.

sacrilege, sinner.

I have to say bad things about a good game, right? Ok...

I think Beyond Good and Evil is boring.

Now, my favorite game that no one likes:

To me UNTIL DAWN is the best game ever made. It just achieves perfectly what it aims to be: a horror movie with a young adults cast.

It is perfect in every scene, angle,line, jump scare, choices.

I just love it to death. And death is always around =)

I thought every aspect of Singularity just screamed of EA trying to do Bioshock and it just killed the game for me, there was a few high points during it but it was just such a clear attempt to bag some of that horroresque fps money that Bioshock drummed up, was pretty shameful throughout the game.

Basically my thought is that if 2k hadn't Gone and made Bioshock the great game that it is Activision would never have created Singularity.

maybe it's because Ninja Gaiden 1 and 2 and Dead Or alive 3 are three of my favorite games ever, and Devil's Third felt like a lot of steps backwards.

wow singularity, I remember that I was hyped but now I can't even remember that game, just like Remember Me from Capcom.