The question is quite simple- what are games you enjoyed that you believed are overrated?

For me, I thought yokai watch was overrated. It's certainly fun, that's for sure. However, the battle system isn't the best it can be and doesn't have online battles against other people. However, those flaws are overlooked due to its great over world and characters.

I also think that Smash Bros. Melee is overrated. Yes, all the smash bros games are obviously fun, but I don't see how people think of it as a God like game. Sm4sh is a much better game overall. 

Uncharted 3 and 4.

Call of Duty

The Last of Us. Enjoyed it and would even go so far as to say it deserved GotY 2013 over freaking Grand Fetch Cutscene 5.

The Witcher 3. It was good, not goty good, not as good as TW2.

Fire Emblem Awakening, does that count?

Why wouldnt it?

because not all good scoring games are considered overrated?

What constitutes "overrated"?

If you consider it overrated, then it counts.