By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 4: A Thief's End Review Thread - MC: 93 / GR: 92.70%

Tagged games:

So only about 1/48th of the amount of signatures Weird Al got to play a Super Bowl halftime show.



Around the Network
LudicrousSpeed said:
Sully_The_Best said:
There is a petition

https://www.change.org/p/washington-post-remove-the-washington-post-review-from-uncharted-4-s-metascore

Well that's pretty sad.


It's pathetic.  A petition for a review of a game that no one here helped create, publish or will profit from.  Hell, some of the people commenting haven't even played it yet.  It is mindboggling how insecure some people can be over something so insignificant. 

Don't get me wrong, after Bloodborne this is hands down my favorite game on PS4 and I don't agree at all with the reviewer's thoughts on the experience.  But to start a petition on Change.org because someone made a bogus review is outragerous.  

Even if the review is eventually removed, will that really make your life that much better?  

Why do you care whether the game is a 93 or a 94 on a website like Metacritic.com?  Does that one point really make or break the game for you?  

Come on, guys... We're better than this.



CenterYharnham said:
LudicrousSpeed said:

Well that's pretty sad.


It's pathetic.  A petition for a review of a game that no one here helped create, publish or will profit from.  Hell, some of the people commenting haven't even played it yet.  It is mindboggling how insecure some people can be over something so insignificant. 

Don't get me wrong, after Bloodborne this is hands down my favorite game on PS4 and I don't agree at all with the reviewer's thoughts on the experience.  But to start a petition on Change.org because someone made a bogus review is outragerous.  

Even if the review is eventually removed, will that really make your life that much better?  

Why do you care whether the game is a 93 or a 94 on a website like Metacritic.com?  Does that one point really make or break the game for you?  

Come on, guys... We're better than this.

Yeah, Troy Baker signed it.  So now what?  I mean, he was intimately involved in the creation of Uncharted 4.  So, since his opinion supercedes all us peons (and yours, I might add), does that mean everyone should sign it now?  



mornelithe said:
CenterYharnham said:


It's pathetic.  A petition for a review of a game that no one here helped create, publish or will profit from.  Hell, some of the people commenting haven't even played it yet.  It is mindboggling how insecure some people can be over something so insignificant. 

Don't get me wrong, after Bloodborne this is hands down my favorite game on PS4 and I don't agree at all with the reviewer's thoughts on the experience.  But to start a petition on Change.org because someone made a bogus review is outragerous.  

Even if the review is eventually removed, will that really make your life that much better?  

Why do you care whether the game is a 93 or a 94 on a website like Metacritic.com?  Does that one point really make or break the game for you?  

Come on, guys... We're better than this.

Yeah, Troy Baker signed it.  So now what?  I mean, he was intimately involved in the creation of Uncharted 4.  So, since his opinion supercedes all us peons (and yours, I might add), does that mean everyone should sign it now?  

Did he really?



CenterYharnham said:
LudicrousSpeed said:

Well that's pretty sad.


It's pathetic.  A petition for a review of a game that no one here helped create, publish or will profit from.  Hell, some of the people commenting haven't even played it yet.  It is mindboggling how insecure some people can be over something so insignificant. 

Don't get me wrong, after Bloodborne this is hands down my favorite game on PS4 and I don't agree at all with the reviewer's thoughts on the experience.  But to start a petition on Change.org because someone made a bogus review is outragerous.  

Even if the review is eventually removed, will that really make your life that much better?  

Why do you care whether the game is a 93 or a 94 on a website like Metacritic.com?  Does that one point really make or break the game for you?  

Come on, guys... We're better than this.

I don't know about that  

Agreed with your post though. 



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png

Around the Network
KLXVER said:
mornelithe said:

Yeah, Troy Baker signed it.  So now what?  I mean, he was intimately involved in the creation of Uncharted 4.  So, since his opinion supercedes all us peons (and yours, I might add), does that mean everyone should sign it now?  

Did he really?

Yeah, and shared it on Twitter.



mornelithe said:
CenterYharnham said:


It's pathetic.  A petition for a review of a game that no one here helped create, publish or will profit from.  Hell, some of the people commenting haven't even played it yet.  It is mindboggling how insecure some people can be over something so insignificant. 

Don't get me wrong, after Bloodborne this is hands down my favorite game on PS4 and I don't agree at all with the reviewer's thoughts on the experience.  But to start a petition on Change.org because someone made a bogus review is outragerous.  

Even if the review is eventually removed, will that really make your life that much better?  

Why do you care whether the game is a 93 or a 94 on a website like Metacritic.com?  Does that one point really make or break the game for you?  

Come on, guys... We're better than this.

Yeah, Troy Baker signed it.  So now what?  I mean, he was intimately involved in the creation of Uncharted 4.  So, since his opinion supercedes all us peons (and yours, I might add), does that mean everyone should sign it now?  

Not at all.  If people involved in making the game want to dispute a bogus review then I think they should.  

I don't think, however, that it should involve any of us or a petition started on Change.org.  

You know why Naughty Dog isn't getting involved with this one guy's negative opinion?  Because they have confidence in the fantastic game they've created and don't care about one bogus review that no one took seriously in the first place.  I think it's time we grow up and do the same.  



CenterYharnham said:
mornelithe said:

Yeah, Troy Baker signed it.  So now what?  I mean, he was intimately involved in the creation of Uncharted 4.  So, since his opinion supercedes all us peons (and yours, I might add), does that mean everyone should sign it now?  

Not at all.  If people involved in making the game want to dispute a bogus review then I think they should.  

I don't think, however, that it should involve any of us or a petition started on Change.org.  

You know why Naughty Dog isn't getting involved with this one guy's negative opinion?  Because they have confidence in the fantastic game they've created and don't care about one bogus review that no one took seriously in the first place.  I think it's time we grow up and do the same.  

Yeah, but you weren't involved in making the game, so your opinion is irrelevant.  I defer to Troy Baker here :)

Bolded: Obviously, an invalid statement.  Metacritic took it seriously enough to utilize the score in their meta. 



mornelithe said:
KLXVER said:

Did he really?

Yeah, and shared it on Twitter.

I mean cool for him, but do petitions ever work? 



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png

BraLoD said:
94 from WCCFtech

Never head of them, but cool if that's added to MC! 

Edit: FUCK! Wanted that 1000th post. 

Whatever 999th post is kinda cool (not really) Sulks in room. 



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png