Samus Aran said:
BF is much more of a TPS than Uncharted lol. How many people play Uncharted online? Most people play Uncharted for the over the top action sequences and story. Purely as a TPS Uncharted is unremarkable. Proven by the fact that the online isn't very populated.
BF III will sell more than Uncharted and Gears.
Sales aren't always indicative of quality anyway. Being the best is subjective. Splatoon is a new IP that released this year, so many people haven't even played it yet.
|
I don't agree with any of that. I don't see how the multiplayer of Uncharted and how many people continued or not playing that multiplayer is any indicative of how good a third person shooter it is. You can't judge the single player gameplay because of it's online component.
Both sales and continued online activity could be both seen as endorsements by gamers. I too believe though that sales are not necessarily any indicative of quality.
Going back to Uncharted and the "Uncharted and no huge continued online activity thing" you wrote, are you somehow arguing that Uncharted doesn't have remarkable gameplay because you think that people played it and got tired of it and that this somehow makes it a "proven fact" that Uncharted is not a "remarkable" third person shooter? Then I guess you believe that after 100+ million consoles sold by Nintendo with the Wii, the lack of continued sales for the next Nintendo console, the WiiU, is a "proven fact" that Nintendo games are not remarkable games in their respective genres, because people saw, came, played and weren't back again this gen to buy the WiiU.