By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Mafia Round 70 - Smash Brothers - Wahahaha! Wario Wins! (And Mafia Too I Guess...)

Clyde32 said:
impertinence said:
Wow, that was completely botched. I thought Wonk had secured the hammer vote as well, seeing as the day ended pretty much as soon as he voted.

I went along with the latest plan as well, so I protected myself. Going back now it seems that Stefl must have gotten the hammer vote after all, and I should have protected Wonk instead. So the question now is who did Stefl target, according to the plan as I thought it was in place he targeted me, which makes Khans scan on me a scan on Stefl instead. Unless Stefl followed one of the other plans and targeted Khan?


Also, if everyone thought Wonk got the hammer vote, why did the mafia target him? Did they know he didn't get it?

I knew Wonk didn't get the hammer vote because of what Prof said. He said the Settle It in Smash didn't reset the votes, only threw out the ones that were for other players. I couldn't do anything about it though since i don't have any active powers and assumed that everyone understood what Prof said



My Hummingbird

3DS Friend Code: 047387541842

Around the Network

I really don't think it makes much sense to think Spurge was a miller. For one, I would think the flip would reveal him as a miller if he indeed was, second if Spurge was a miller it doesn't make sense that he never claimed it. If he was miller he should have claimed that immediately, or at the very least not lie and force suspicion on himself. In any case, after he was scanned he would definitely have claimed. Anything else makes absolutely no sense.

I think it makes much more sense to find out why Khan scanned him as scum when he wasn't. Either the scan was redirected or corrupted somehow, or he was lying about it. I guess Stefl could have targeted Spurge and redirected the scan onto himself (not sure if that is possible with the different confirmations we have, would have to go back and recheck this). Or, Khan is not really a cop and has been playing us the whole game. In this case, White was likely the real cop and Khan stole his claim. It also likely means the Hylian is scum as well and the whole scan me please and confirmation was set up to clear him.



Clyde32 said:
impertinence said:
Wow, that was completely botched. I thought Wonk had secured the hammer vote as well, seeing as the day ended pretty much as soon as he voted.

I went along with the latest plan as well, so I protected myself. Going back now it seems that Stefl must have gotten the hammer vote after all, and I should have protected Wonk instead. So the question now is who did Stefl target, according to the plan as I thought it was in place he targeted me, which makes Khans scan on me a scan on Stefl instead. Unless Stefl followed one of the other plans and targeted Khan?


Also, if everyone thought Wonk got the hammer vote, why did the mafia target him? Did they know he didn't get it?

If you go back and re-read the end of day post, you'll see that Wonk is not counted in the end of day lynch by prof. But that is the only indication that Stefl did hammer. I completely missed it, but saw it right now when I went back to see if I missed Prof declearing who had the hammer immunity like he has done up until now.



AstroGamer said:
So we have
Hylian - Voyeur
Khan - Item Cop
Clyde - Master Hand
Me - Princess
Radish - Friendly Neighbor
Imp - Psychologist
Stefl - can't remember but I'm getting a Town feeling from him

I'm not really a pshyciatrist, more like a doctor/pshyciatrist combo. I can protect one target at Night, and if that target is a SK, he is cured.



Okay, so, everyone who targeted imp - please let your beautiful voices be heard~



Around the Network

btw - the princess not dying seems utterly weird~



Also, worth noting that there was no janitoring tonight after tonights kill... weird how nobody noticed that...



Stefl1504 said:
btw - the princess not dying seems utterly weird~


I'm confused by that as well. I did say something about it not neccessarily being activated by night kills, but I'm not sure about it since the wording was a bit weird.

On your second statement, I actually missed that but Janitor is usually x-shot, isn't it?



My Hummingbird

3DS Friend Code: 047387541842

AstroGamer said:
Stefl1504 said:
btw - the princess not dying seems utterly weird~


I'm confused by that as well. I did say something about it not neccessarily being activated by night kills, but I'm not sure about it since the wording was a bit weird.

On your second statement, I actually missed that but Janitor is usually x-shot, isn't it?

not really

It could be that he is x-shot, it could be that he is not

>not necessarily being activated by night-kills seems a bit spooky and fishy...



impertinence said:
I really don't think it makes much sense to think Spurge was a miller. For one, I would think the flip would reveal him as a miller if he indeed was, second if Spurge was a miller it doesn't make sense that he never claimed it. If he was miller he should have claimed that immediately, or at the very least not lie and force suspicion on himself. In any case, after he was scanned he would definitely have claimed. Anything else makes absolutely no sense.

I think it makes much more sense to find out why Khan scanned him as scum when he wasn't. Either the scan was redirected or corrupted somehow, or he was lying about it. I guess Stefl could have targeted Spurge and redirected the scan onto himself (not sure if that is possible with the different confirmations we have, would have to go back and recheck this). Or, Khan is not really a cop and has been playing us the whole game. In this case, White was likely the real cop and Khan stole his claim. It also likely means the Hylian is scum as well and the whole scan me please and confirmation was set up to clear him.

I don't see why i would lie about it. If i were scum and running a deception, i would have heaped suspicion on Spurge in the first "Settle it in Smash" way back when, and not outed padib who had very little suspicion against him until i decided it had to be him (and it turns out i was really right about that: the other three of us were, in fact, town). 

I'm currently running on the "my power is more useless than it seems" card, myself. 

At this point, though, it's either Hylian or somebody who has voted for scum in the past.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.