He said what his role was. He has high defense and no special abilities. Town is the faction on defense at night, so I think it does suggest he's town. If he weren't being honest, he'd have suggested a non-vanilla but believable role. We've gotten as much out of him as we're going to get without getting him modkilled.

I really do think he's town, and at the very least, there's a better lynch in Astro. I know we won't get a reaction from him, but I'm not sure it's that critical. Regardless, we're not getting a White Eagle lynch because I already changed my vote, so it's a tie now.

This is your second mafia game..and I don't beleive you've ever played a game like this before..So how do you know 0 is the usual defence?

My opinion is this site is awful to sift through on my phone. 

Going to read through everything and make my decision. See if there's anything I've or everyone else have missed before making my decision. 

All of this stuff is useful for town to know (about how little time you put into reading the thread etc.), don't keep it secret until you're almost killed! If you have a hard time covering everything, it's ok to ask other people for important point that have happened, links to the major evens or whatever. Just contribute what you can, it's always better than sitting on your hands and trying to become invisible.

I can help with Voting astro, but first I will need 2-3 bullet points why he may be Scum. I am uncertain currently of him - was not following him for a while.

I currently hate the situation we're in.  I feel like I have to chose between 3 bad lynches. I'll revote before the end of the Day for sure but I'm still unsure what to do.

I'd also like to officially prod burgrimmar. I don't think he wants to play mafia, and even if he does any replacement would probably be much better. My hope is that Day 2 starts with someone else playing for him.

From WoW's role PM. I can't think of wording it differently without quoting a section of what WoW wrote in brackets straight after telling me my stats.

That was my 22k post. Huh

Also I'm 99% sure the standard defence is not 0, looking at the ops, and my PM. Perhaps you have no special powers?

Especially since you claim you have more defence..You saying that 0 is the usual defense when by all rights if your role call is real then I don't know how you can know 0 is the usual defense. it feels coached. Am I wrong on this?