Poring through 1400 comments to find the one time you mentioned how you wish the day would hurry up is not my idea of a fun time, spurge. I wouldn't even know where to look.
Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.
Did some more reading, and yeah, spurge was advocating for caution a lot.
Okay, let's make things interesting. Vote: Radishhead
I think he's the ghost.
Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.
Unvote
Didn't read Trucks' thing earlier. Now i feel silly.
Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.
| Mr Khan said: I really don't think Impertinence is it. Based on what we know so far, my theory is 1 scum faction, 5 or 6 strong, and 1 independent (the perp). So scum could now be down to 4 or 3 already. So there are 8 or 9 of us in town right now. I am town, whiteeagle seems clean. Carl i think has been cleared. Trucks, Impertinence, and TheProf have worked in a bloc so far and largely been responsible for busting Protoss. Padib i'm willing to trust for the moment because he's giving a consistent read and his flavor helps explain the no-kill from last night. Although he could be the nuke and lying to protect himself. So your scum suspects are most likely EricFabian, Conegamer, Wright, and Wonktonodi in that order. Nuke suspects are Radish and Spurge, maybe padib as an outside chance. Again, I'd start with grilling those two. We need to knock out the perpetrator to keep the game length going. |
Looks like you have me with some bad company.
Though your list is similar to mine.You and eagle both claimed same. One pair. So mostly trustworthy with slight chance if risky scum. Radish and TOS are a new pair. TOS I had mostly trusted before though it had started to fade plus there was some meta there. But again another pair that could be scum taking risk.
Both cases though it makes it very unlikely either are the nuke.
Padib when he was first taking about reveals in day 5 seemed like terrible idea, though the more he has said has made him more trustworthy.
Carl screams town and scum to me. Town from meta scum from, things I posted day 2
Prof I could see bussing team mates. So no congratulations until I know he's also town. But if he's pulling that off as the nuker, great job on his part since I really only seem him as town or mafia.
Imp I find myself agreeing with plenty, while that always worries me little, I trust when he's not stingy tap to use logic can follow and agree with. If scum he us doing well at hiding it.
Myself I know I'm town, so I can eliminate one further.
Eric, Ryan, Cone and Wright.
Ryan I've felt has helped the most with scum hunting. Eric the least. The other two have made me suspicious at varies points both for what they say and what don't say as well as for some meta.
TruckOSaurus said:
That's the problem. I can't attack, I only defend myself when attacked. So what good is your ability now? |
Can't attack either here but, his ability might make it that the scum would more likely to die themselves in attack fine there defence value would be gone if I'm understanding Padib the rules correctly. So potentiality helpful if the scum die before they can kill off town.
Padib why did you out yourself the other Day?
I don't understand what your motivation was.
padib said:
It was to explain my differing win condition to Carl's, as well as to break scum's spirit after a 2-townie killing night. |
Why did you feel the need to explain your differing win condition?
Why did you feel it was necessary to break scum's spirit? We lynched one on day 1. That's bad enough.
I dob't feel like your reasons are strong enough. Maybe in your opinion, they are, but it doesn't seem that way to me.
| padib said: And I'll add to it that I didn't feel like they could do anything serious about it. I may have gotten a little overconfident but so far it turned out ok. |
Hmm, I wouldn't say ok is a good description. Now we're all wondering who and what you are.
Are you a third party? You might have written this before, but I might've missed it.
I'm just making observations, but it seemed to make you really jumpy and defensive.
No ghosts were mentioned in the OP. That is factually inaccurate. We've simply agreed by consensus that the nuker is probably a ghost. A day 1 scum lynch is literally the best possible outcome of day 1. Sure it wasn't the nuker, but still really great.
Why explain your differing condition at all? You had no reason to stick your neck out there. Who would wrongfully suspect you when you didn't have to say anything in the first place.
I don't know why I'm still alive, and I don't think that's a good question either. How do you know I'm prancing along unscathed? How do you know I haven't been attacked?
padib said:
If you have, then why haven't you informed town about it? Also, your nuker =/= ghost correction is an unnecessary nitpik and you know it. I'm not being jumpy, I'm just making comments about you. I think asking how come you're alive is an excellent question, as a matter of fact I have another one for you. Is it possible that you went from one game (FE mafia) being a full vote failure play to this game where you were spot on every one of your votes by the natural refinement of your intuition? I would be much more inclined to suspect that you have been bussing some of your teammates. Also, why did you ask me about my motivation on outing myself almost 6 human days after the fact, especially right at the moment I shed proper suspicion on Wright? |
We've already been warned not to talk about it, and I agree that it's unfair play...but I have the normal town pm.
It's not unecessary. It's even odder that you've now mentioned ghosts plural twice.
You are being jumpy. Anyone would objectively agree. I asked questions, and you responded with pointed suspicions. That's called being jumpy. You felt threatened, and returned the favor.
Why am I alive? Why are you alive? Why is trucks alive? Why is impertinence alive?
You think I bussed two teammates? Hmm. Fair point given how devious I can be, but it's also a stretch. If you consider my scum play to be capable of ANYTHING, then you will always find SOMETHING suspicious. That's not detective work. That's confirmation bias.
I've been in Japan. I haven't been able to ask all the questions I've wanted to. Now I'm back, so I asked you what your motivation was. It just seems weird to just go and be like, "hey scum look at me, I'm really dangerous. Also, I'm invulnerable tonight" I'm curious as to why you did that.
Also, you've answered every question I've posted today, but left out one. Are you third party?
Essay Pro
About Us |
Terms of Use |
Privacy Policy |
Advertise |
Staff |
Contact
Display As Desktop
Display As Mobile
© 2006-2024 VGChartz Ltd. All rights reserved.
