Alright, let's see.

EricFabian thinks I'm the nuker. I also think he's the nuker because he felt interested with the bombing trivia I gave at the beginning of the game.

Padib's message gave me a nuker vibe too. The reasoning is, he claims he's hazardous to the zerg or whatever enemy goes here, and that no matter if they try going for him they will regret it. Meaning he could kill them all with the bomb, indeed (killing us all in the process as well), so his speech isn't pure bluffing. Outside that, could be scum trying to cover his back, or could be town looking for trouble. I'm inclined to think he's this last one.

Prof went back and defended me, even though he really didn't have any reasons to, outside being a buddy. I call him town. He also gives interesting insight, though he's usually under fire from the other users.

WhiteEagle keeps messing us with his role powers, or role condition, or whatever. He gets a scum vibe from me, because it could be easy to just come out and say it already, instead of walking in circles. The fact that he has gone to these lenghts to not say it also makes me thing he has a secret he needs to protect, but not necessarily something evil (i.e being scum); instead, a power that could be helpful to townies.

impertinence is a dude with a sharp eye and witty comments. Can't say anything about him. He could literally be anything in this game based on what he has been saying and how he analizes things.

I'd say Carl is town based on how he went all over me. Judging what WoW told me, also, I have even less reasons to doubt his town condition.

Mr. Khan is new to the table. I'm going to say scum as a placeholder.

Conegamer isn't that much active (kinda like me), so I have not much data to work with. I'm going to say townie as placeholder.

Wonk makes small but specific comments at precise times. He has done several things to cast suspicious on him, but all things considered, he joined Carl when he was confronting me, and again, given what WoW told me, I have not much reasons to doubt him either. Doubt he is scum, so far I think he's town.

I'd say Spurge is scum because of his insistence that I should post more. Maybe he wants me to lynch some townie so that he gets away with it.

Radishead has hardly commented, though he gave me insight of Starcraft's units. I'm going to say nuker as placeholder (would explain his lack of activity, since he doesn't want to really let anything slip). I'll investigate this later, though EricFabian and Padib are also possible nukers.

Smeags is a mistery.

So what were you told coming in, exactly?

Also it may be early in the day as you've only just started, but what do you think of different people so far? It would be interesting to hear an almost knee-jerk reaction on gut instinct from someone who has only just jumped in.

With regards to EricFabian, well at least it's something. It's pretty much what he said right from the get go, and there's still no explanation of his action. At this point I feel he's just unable to grasp the concept of the game at this point, because if he was Mafia they'd not allow this activity (I would expect). 

With regards to Wright, that's some pretty good analysis. It's nice to hear your opinion and there's some good thoughts there (though I disagree with my lack of activity particularly on this second day). It does make a good point though. I would like to request a prod for Radish. He was last online 10 hours ago but hasn't posted in over a day (even with a load of people questioning his activity). When you get back, Radish, might I ask who you think the nuker is?

And the other people whom I am looking at aside from Sparks are WhiteEagle, Wonktonodi and Radish.

I can't really say. My goal would be to take a look at who Astrogamer was interacting with day one, since he's the only incontrovertible lead we have so far. That's likely how i'll base my vote ToDay, then next day i'll be more on board.

We have other confirmed people as well, don't forget! Nicklesbe was very active and at least some of the people he interacted with probably knew he was town. In the very least you can go back and in full confidence knoew tht his observations are made from the angle of trying to find scum. Same goes for Hylian, and while he had very little time with us, he got killed for a reason. He was also looking out for town.

All i recall is the last game where town barked up the wrong tree the ENTIRE game, so i'm a little wary of using who got murdered as a sign.

It's number 1.  HP is not increased or decreased, at all.

In this game town has barked up the right tree so far. I still recommend looking at how people have responded to all of the people we have confirmed, not just Astro. In fact, the peculiar lynch choice of Hylian could be a hint that he was getting close to scum. For example. Anyway, your call of course.

@Whrite I used my role to say it as a [very successful] defence against other players in day 1, where at one point I was the prime lynch target.

So you can only use it on day 1?

Whut?