By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Fire Emblem Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

padib said:
Nicklesbe said:
padib said:
Town, what is our case on RCT?

- Flip-flopping (prof to outlaw).
- Distancing/buddying with prof.
- Inactivity and lack of a defense on a case against him.

What am I missing?


damage control/ trying to prevent analyses of players.

Thanks Nickles. Remind me the post for this one pls.


http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6567002



http://www.youtube.com/v/AoOOpLpcF28 http://www.youtube.com/v/CphFZGH5030

All Hail the Jester King. The King is back, and I am still a dirty girl prof ;)

Around the Network
padib said:

You should tell him, this is a team game so you shouldn't be withholding important information for us to work with. It's not clear to me either honestly.

We withhold information as not to alert mafia to it. Thanks for all of these, by the way ¡

leh sigh. *deletes more mean stuff*

Would you please stop blurting out everything that pops into your head?



padib said:
Nicklesbe said:
padib said:

Thanks Nickles. Remind me the post for this one pls.


http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6567002

I remember now, ty.

Let's remind ourselves of this if he flips mafia of his link to prof, and by teamplaying, Sparks.

Also badnwagonning, which I consider a tell but Im new so not really sure if that is good justification or not.



http://www.youtube.com/v/AoOOpLpcF28 http://www.youtube.com/v/CphFZGH5030

All Hail the Jester King. The King is back, and I am still a dirty girl prof ;)

Sparks said:
I wanna get rid of IkePoR.

I just remembered when prof was a bit too eager about protecting Ike. He really wanted to get Trucks to play in Ike's place. Maybe he wanted a veteran on his team?

He left anyway. I wanna see what he flips.


He'll be back though. Or rather someone, perhaps Trucks, will. Why would you want to get rid of Ike if you think prof is town and prof wanted him? Are you saying you suspect prof? Yet you're not acting on it? You know I suspect you of being on his team, right? WhiteEagle left too, why not see what he flips? That's sarcasm, I don't think we really know much about WhiteEagle since he left so soon. I'm just saying, that phrasing "wanna see what he flips" suggests you're not confident about him. You honestly seem like you're more confident of prof, but you want to keep him in the game purely because you just love prof as a player so much. Whatever, I'm not saying vote for prof. In fact don't, because that would just be a waste at this point. But at least do something to make me think you're not on his team. I don't care what anyone says, I'm convinced there are multiple mafia factions, that prof is on one of them, and as for the other one, I have my eye on the people voting for Cone.



HylianSwordsman said:
Sparks said:
I wanna get rid of IkePoR.

I just remembered when prof was a bit too eager about protecting Ike. He really wanted to get Trucks to play in Ike's place. Maybe he wanted a veteran on his team?

He left anyway. I wanna see what he flips.


He'll be back though. Or rather someone, perhaps Trucks, will. Why would you want to get rid of Ike if you think prof is town and prof wanted him? Are you saying you suspect prof? Yet you're not acting on it? You know I suspect you of being on his team, right? WhiteEagle left too, why not see what he flips? That's sarcasm, I don't think we really know much about WhiteEagle since he left so soon. I'm just saying, that phrasing "wanna see what he flips" suggests you're not confident about him. You honestly seem like you're more confident of prof, but you want to keep him in the game purely because you just love prof as a player so much. Whatever, I'm not saying vote for prof. In fact don't, because that would just be a waste at this point. But at least do something to make me think you're not on his team. I don't care what anyone says, I'm convinced there are multiple mafia factions, that prof is on one of them, and as for the other one, I have my eye on the people voting for Cone.

I must have missed it when whiteagle left. Do we know who his replacement is? Either way I don't think we will know for sure until day 2 how many teams there are. I've only seen evidence that supports one. Only thing I'm confident now tho is that RCT is so I would recommend you look over the arguments that have been made towards him and if you feel he is too then please change your vote to him.



http://www.youtube.com/v/AoOOpLpcF28 http://www.youtube.com/v/CphFZGH5030

All Hail the Jester King. The King is back, and I am still a dirty girl prof ;)

Around the Network
theprof00 said:
Trucks is a very good player. Do me it would be nice to have someone who is a pro also.
if there is no replacement we'll see quickly how wrll I am at determining who is what.

As far as two factions there is simply no reason to discuss it without evidence. It is a waste of time and a distraction.
words writes things in such a way that you cannot confirm anything. Thus is the mark of a good mod. No evidence, no discussion.


I already mentioned how he should have written it so as not to be able to confirm anything. He should have said "any other mafia factions" not "the other mafia faction". So is that the sign of a bad mod, or are you just downplaying this because it helps my case against you? And people are finding plenty to discuss here, and I've already pointed to the evidence. And you're suddenly on the defensive. Either way you've admitted the possibility of two factions, and the town should be considering this, because it has consequences. Not as much as for mafia though, who should be hiding it, which you are trying to now.

As for trucks replacing, if he's a good player, it shouldn't matter if he's town or mafia. That said, I don't think just because a good player is going to replace someone means we shouldn't vote that spot out before the replacement happens. If that spot is mafia, it's mafia. However, I do agree that IkePoR isn't terribly suspicious, enough so that I wouldn't vote for him on day one.

 

But enough about you, my vote against you is pretty much a null vote since no one agrees, I only keep it because I still think you're mafia and you're the one I'm most confident of, and the only two choices that might lead to a lynch at the moment seem like clear townies to me. What do you think of RCT? People are making a case against him, and it doesn't all involve him buddying up with you.



HylianSwordsman said:

He'll be back though.*{1} Or rather someone, perhaps Trucks, will. Why would you want to get rid of Ike if you think prof is town and prof wanted him? Are you saying you suspect prof?*{2} Yet you're not acting on it? You know I suspect you of being on his team, right? WhiteEagle left too, why not see what he flips? That's sarcasm, I don't think we really know much about WhiteEagle since he left so soon. I'm just saying, that phrasing "wanna see what he flips" suggests you're not confident about him. You honestly seem like you're more confident of prof, but you want to keep him in the game purely because you just love prof as a player so much. Whatever, I'm not saying vote for prof. In fact don't, because that would just be a waste at this point. But at least do something to make me think you're not on his team. I don't care what anyone says, I'm convinced there are multiple mafia factions, that prof is on one of them, and as for the other one, I have my eye on the people voting for Cone.

1. No, he won't be back. Words of Wisdom said he asked to be replaced. I don't know if Trucks will replace him either. WhiteEaglePL is on vaca.

2. Never in any of my posts defending prof did I say I thought he was town. I said he's good for investigation, and he's just nice to have here, though you might disagree.

I think I'll just post this snippet here. It's a few days old, but still good; random, cryptic, non-contributing posts by IkePoR: one, two, three, four. Basically most of his posts are like this, and the other ones hint that he's not paying attention. Dodges people's questioning, never answers, never has anything meaningful to say. I know it's nothing solid, but I don't like him all the same. Though, I'm not saying I wanna lynch him right now either.



Nicklesbe said:

I must have missed it when whiteagle left*{}. Do we know who his replacement is? Either way I don't think we will know for sure until day 2 how many teams there are. I've only seen evidence that supports one. Only thing I'm confident now tho is that RCT is so I would recommend you look over the arguments that have been made towards him and if you feel he is too then please change your vote to him.

He didn't leave, not like IkePoR did. WhiteEagle's on vaca.



Sparks said:
Nicklesbe said:

I must have missed it when whiteagle left*{}. Do we know who his replacement is? Either way I don't think we will know for sure until day 2 how many teams there are. I've only seen evidence that supports one. Only thing I'm confident now tho is that RCT is so I would recommend you look over the arguments that have been made towards him and if you feel he is too then please change your vote to him.

He didn't leave, not like IkePoR did. WhiteEagle's on vaca.

That explains why I didn't see it then. Was just going back to find it, ya saved me some trouble thanks.



http://www.youtube.com/v/AoOOpLpcF28 http://www.youtube.com/v/CphFZGH5030

All Hail the Jester King. The King is back, and I am still a dirty girl prof ;)

Nicklesbe said:


I was already pretty sure for reasons already stated. I tried to get as much input as possible and so far everyone has pretty much agreed. I asked you and you wouldn't mind. So I was on the cusp, but this really seems like a strong play/ My number two option would have been to vote for outlaw but outlaw kinda defused some suspicion when he defended himself and opened up more. So he is using his ability and I can't vote for outlaw so the only real choice I see is RCT. So it has convinced me because it's a strong play and I haven't seen much to convince me of voting elsewhere.


So do you believe padib's claim? It's certainly an outstanding claim. Either he's telling the truth or he's just really determined to keep outlaw alive, suggesting they're on a team. I know you suspect him, but at this point, I'm quickly losing suspicion on him. Look at how him and RCT respond to allegations of inactivity. RCT shows up and makes himself even more suspicious, outlaw shows up and doesn't seem to have anything to hide. Either outlaw is just has a really good poker face or he's town. Of course, outlaw does have a good poker face, at least based on my interactions with him in COMG, but also based on those interactions, I think outlaw's behavior is perfectly normal. You know what? Yeah, consider this my official statement that I am 100% sure as of this moment that outlaw is town. Given that outlaw is town, and padib wants him alive, I think that means padib is town too. I suppose that doesn't mean his role claim is true, as it could be made up because he's convinced outlaw is town, or he could be leaving out details. Actually, it's probably best for the town if he is leaving out details.

@padib I hope you're telling the truth, and I hope that's not all there is to your role. If it isn't, might want to listen to Sparks and not reveal anymore, at least not today.