although the original post is a bit of a ramble, I know where you are coming from, when sony entered the gaming scene i was reluctant to buy into the PS brand. I hated how they were making gaming trendy to non gamers. They were truely the pioneers of the casual gamer, which back then was classed as 'mainstream gaming', much the same as the wii situation now.
When it was launched (the PS1) it had nothing but hype to fuel sales and the saturn absolutely wiped the floor with it, Sega Rally, VF and SFZ were top of my priorities and I couldnt see any need for a PS1, I stuck to my guns and paid more for the underpowered Saturn while everyone else bought the new sony with the 1 track wonder, Ridge Racer.
Over time Sony just gained too many third party franchises, as well as many being born on it, They were incredibly lucky and did everything right back then. Its still the case, if you want to play the majority of Japan produced games, you still need a playstation and the fact it now comes with BD is a bonus, just as the PS2 was with DVD.
I think Sony's main problem is they are no longer appealing to that mainstream/casual gamer they invented. they started the ball rolling and nintendo picked it up when it was at full momentum and gave it another kick.
Although I do still dislike Sony, or more accurately the Playstation, Id take a japanese produced machine over anything M$ produce without a second thought. At least with major Japanese support Sonys console relains to be a Console, not a console trying to be a PC.
It is/was a case of since Sega have gone (and untill the wii, so had Nintnedo), Sony were the only option.











