By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Making a Case for QTEs in Games

The QTEs in Uncharted aren't too offensive, but in my experience most of them degrade the video game experience. I get that it's a way to bridge gameplay with cinema scenes, but it tends to prove unsatisfying on both fronts.



Around the Network
kitler53 said:
i don't hate QTEs. i enjoyed heavy rain very much. i enjoyed them in the god of war franchise. what i hate is unexpected QTEs. tomb raider had a few of those. QTEs where you've not used any QTEs in over an hour seeing several cut scene along the way that suddenly BAM the next cut scene has a QTE that insta-kills you if you miss it.

i like them in games like puppeteer where they only used them in boss fights but they used them in every boss fight and the first event was a gimme to start the sequence. those kinds can be fun.

I quit and uninstalled Tomb Raider in the first couple of hours because of QTEs.  I mean, bloody hell, I died three times to sudden QTEs and simply had enough.

In Crysis 2, I died after a long cut-scene because I was NOT expecting a QTE.  I wasn't even holding my controller.  I ended up having to play the entire LEVEL over, not just the cut-scene.  That's as hard as I've raged at a game, ever.

Far Cry 3 made me SPAM the C key on my keyboard in order to not die from sudden animal attacks.  I mean, what the fuck?  It's the bloody CROUCH key, for cat's sake, and isn't easy or intuitive to reach quickly.

Those are a few of the reasons I hate QTEs.  They are often used in horrible ways, where you're not expecting them, you don't know how long you have to hit the key, and you don't know if you need to spam the key or not.  Really, they normally suck and I generally avoid games where I know they're used a lot.

Gaming is about forming associations to the point where they flow naturally.  You're not pressing X, you're jumping, or shooting, or hitting something with a cat-damned tuna.  QTEs shatter that suspension of disbelief.  Suddenly, all you're doing is consciously spamming a button.  I don't like that.



Well written, i agree. People bash QTE unfairly a lot of times.



The Rhythm genre is basically just one big QTE orgy =D
Now Im thinking about Miku and... um, yeah personally Im a fan of well used QTEs. Goodbye!
*Runs away*



pokoko said:
kitler53 said:
i don't hate QTEs. i enjoyed heavy rain very much. i enjoyed them in the god of war franchise. what i hate is unexpected QTEs. tomb raider had a few of those. QTEs where you've not used any QTEs in over an hour seeing several cut scene along the way that suddenly BAM the next cut scene has a QTE that insta-kills you if you miss it.

i like them in games like puppeteer where they only used them in boss fights but they used them in every boss fight and the first event was a gimme to start the sequence. those kinds can be fun.

I quit and uninstalled Tomb Raider in the first couple of hours because of QTEs.  I mean, bloody hell, I died three times to sudden QTEs and simply had enough.

In Crysis 2, I died after a long cut-scene because I was NOT expecting a QTE.  I wasn't even holding my controller.  I ended up having to play the entire LEVEL over, not just the cut-scene.  That's as hard as I've raged at a game, ever.

Far Cry 3 made me SPAM the C key on my keyboard in order to not die from sudden animal attacks.  I mean, what the fuck?  It's the bloody CROUCH key, for cat's sake, and isn't easy or intuitive to reach quickly.

Those are a few of the reasons I hate QTEs.  They are often used in horrible ways, where you're not expecting them, you don't know how long you have to hit the key, and you don't know if you need to spam the key or not.  Really, they normally suck and I generally avoid games where I know they're used a lot.

Gaming is about forming associations to the point where they flow naturally.  You're not pressing X, you're jumping, or shooting, or hitting something with a cat-damned tuna.  QTEs shatter that suspension of disbelief.  Suddenly, all you're doing is consciously spamming a button.  I don't like that.

that's exactly what i'm talking about.

in a game like heavy rain where every interaction is a QTE they can be fun.  but when unexpected they can be the most rage inducing game mechanic ever.  i think that's why they get such a bad name is because of how many rage quits they've created.  they are just soo easy to abuse.



Around the Network

JASON

http://www.kongregate.com/games/kthorjensen/press-x-to-jason

The only good use of QTEs, and it's been around since before you were born.



WHERE IS MY KORORINPA 3