By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - MK8 Is the Highest Rated Next Gen Game So Far This Year :) Will Any Games Top It, If so Which One(s)?

episteme on 19 May 2014
tbone51 said:


Not trying to get anybody mad, and im not doing it cuz of being an Ninty fan. I didnt add Pushmo for example to 3ds list.

Im just excluding ports/remakes/indies. Thats all

Pushmo is developed by Intelligent Systems and published by Nintendo. It's not an indie game.

Are there any indie games that are expected to score 90 or more?



Around the Network
tbone51 on 19 May 2014
Kresnik said:
tbone51 said:

Im just excluding ports/remakes/indies. Thats all


Yes.  But why?


Ok fine if i do add indie games is there any thats new this year on next gen only? (with an 87+ aside from towerfall)



Talal on 19 May 2014
tbone51 said:


indiesI dont hate indies, nowhee close. I made a 3ds meta thread yesterday and didn't add pushmo 91 to the opening.

Also Dillon Western Roll is one of my favorite 3ds games. I just wanted to do a list without ports/remakes/indies.

Maybe im wrong, but it seems some people get mad. I think its more cuz of the vita? Its heavily an indie HH. Like i said before, not trying to get anybody mad but its main games that we kno, not necessarily indies :-/

Ex: Comparing tv shows with 1-2min clips (clips being Indies). Not everybody wants to categorize all of it together


So in your opinion indie games are lesser games and shouldn't be compared to non indie games?

Although that might be true sometimes there are a lot of indie games that destroy "main" games in terms of quality and amount of content.



gergroy on 19 May 2014

I expect destiny, batman, and X will all do better. Outside chance quantum break could as well.



tbone51 on 19 May 2014
RolStoppable said:
tbone51 said:

indiesI dont hate indies, nowhee close. I made a 3ds meta thread yesterday and didn't add pushmo 91 to the opening.

Also Dillon Western Roll is one of my favorite 3ds games. I just wanted to do a list without ports/remakes/indies.

Maybe im wrong, but it seems some people get mad. I think its more cuz of the vita? Its heavily an indie HH. Like i said before, not trying to get anybody mad but its main games that we kno, not necessarily indies :-/

Ex: Comparing tv shows with 1-2min clips (clips being Indies). Not everybody wants to categorize all of it together

Gosh, tbone. You have absolutely no idea what the terms you throw around mean.

What you have been doing with these threads is a look at retail games, excluding remakes (and excluding ports in those threads for exclusives). Digital-only games were disqualified as well. And that's it.

tbone terminology:

Main game = retail.
Indie = digital-only.


This thread turning into a main game vs indie game!!!

Ok fine indies count MK8 still #1. Lets not count Remakes/Ports. Next gen only!



Around the Network
J_Allard on 19 May 2014

I can understand not including indie games, they are reviewed on a different scale than a full retail release.

 

Btw the answer is Evolve.



Nintentacle on 19 May 2014

Smash Bros., X, and Batman might beat it. Uncharted too if it releases this year.



tbone51 on 19 May 2014
Talal said:
tbone51 said:


indiesI dont hate indies, nowhee close. I made a 3ds meta thread yesterday and didn't add pushmo 91 to the opening.

Also Dillon Western Roll is one of my favorite 3ds games. I just wanted to do a list without ports/remakes/indies.

Maybe im wrong, but it seems some people get mad. I think its more cuz of the vita? Its heavily an indie HH. Like i said before, not trying to get anybody mad but its main games that we kno, not necessarily indies :-/

Ex: Comparing tv shows with 1-2min clips (clips being Indies). Not everybody wants to categorize all of it together


So in your opinion indie games are lesser games and shouldn't be compared to non indie games?

Although that might be true sometimes there are a lot of indie games that destroy "main" games in terms of quality and amount of content.



Yeah, i didn't mean for this to get blown out of the water. I guess i was looking at more of the fact that indies should have it be separated category. Not saying its not countng as a real game. Like i said before, Dillon Western Roll is easily in my top 10 games for 3ds.

tbone51 on 19 May 2014
RolStoppable said:
tbone51 said:

This thread turning into a main game vs indie game!!!

Ok fine indies count MK8 still #1. Lets not count Remakes/Ports. Next gen only!

Right, let's add that too.

tbone terminology:

Next gen = current gen.
Current gen = last gen.


Im going to kill you one day, be it in MK or simply just me hunting you down!!!

I swear i hear people say this still till this day, so i said next gen for this gen. Dont need to be like that :s



sidmeiernintifan on 19 May 2014

I think Super Smash Bros and X will be ranked higher.

Xenoblade has a 92 in Metacritic, Smash Bros Brawl 93.

Mario Kart 8 lost points for 2 reasons, battle mode, and the roster (no diddy, dry bones, birdo etc, while having metal peach and a whole row of babies), it makes me kinda sad knowing that they could have easily had had a game with a metacritic in the mid 90s, it is not like solving that would have been hard.