For me it was the first Silent Hill.

I guess it is was less weird and more "What the @&$#!".

what was da f*** momments?

the first game that popped into my head, and it was amazing

Probably Catherine. Love that game though.

@ aviggo77

One in particular was Lisa's death scene. My buddy and I were playing the game in our apartment and the scene just didn't sit well with us. It is weak sauce compared to some of the stuff you see now but at the time it was one of those "What the &$#%!" moments.

I remember Fatal Frame messing with me too lol...😱.

@the truthhurts
now i get it!

And thats just the intro, wait til you see the cutscenes lol

I saw this game a lot I was younger, but barely picked it up to play it last month and I was suprised by how weird it was haha. I'm loving it though, it has a really good soundtrack too.

PaRappa the Rapper weirdest and worst game ever

A recent one that comes to mind is Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc.