No idea who these guys are but Tomb Raider looked fantastic to me. I think Beyond Two Souls looked better but that game had really small environments.

The site is Xbox only... no PC, PS or Nintendo games.

No it isn't, look at their other award categories. Last of Us gets 3rd in best ending, other PC titles win awards as well.

Here is a comment from an editor of the site:

"Thanks for the comment Mark!

Unfortunately, we aren't big PC gamers. Isaac did play Crysis 3 but only on Xbox 360. I played Battlefield 4 on the Xbox One, which looks great but not amazing, I am sure the PS4 and PC versions look better. We both played Metro: Last Light but on the Xbox 360, which looked a bit rubbish really.

All of our game of the year awards are decided based on games and experiences we actually had. We don't go off hearsay or compressed YouTube videos.

It's also a bit ridiculous to call our article "factually incorrect." It's all opinion and personal preferences.

Thanks,

Ross Hartley
Editor, Hidden Audio Log"

They have ZERO credentials and lost all credibility with that post. No Idea why this thread was even made. Maybe xbox fans needed a tiny stench of good news lol. 

Just ask to them... they only played Xbox version of the games.

Man I must have missed the Xbox version of Last of Us. I bet party chat ruins MP.

You guys are really adorable.

Talk with the editor... they are saying that.

Yes don't even read the comment posted by an editor of the site mentioning them only playing xbox versions of bf4 metro etc... How ignorant.

They mention a few games. You're saying they only play Xbox games. They have different awards up and there are non-Xbox games among them. So per usual, you were wrong.

Its just tthe opinion of one small site. No need for you guys to work overtime to discredit them so much. Its the weekend.

http://www.hiddenaudiolog.com/about-us/

Tell you again that... they are cleary focused in Xbox brand.

And if you read my comment I agree with their choice.