I prefer the XBONE controller tbh. It's much more like the DS3.

Really? Becuse it looks like the 360 controller with a few changes.

Never liked the 360 controller so I'm sure I won't like the One controller.

The sticks are a lot looser and the triggers are as well. It has the same basic ergonomics as the 360 controller, but it felt like I was playing with a DS3. Maybe I just had a bad controller, but personally I loved it. Bumpers weren't the best though.

I used both.

Were your XBONE sticks and triggers somewhat loose?

It was not at the DS3 level but it is a bit loose compared with 360's sticks... the trigger were fine to me... the bumper are terrible.

In terms of ergonomics I felt it better than 360's controller.

Damn I might have to prefer the one's controller since I am a huge fan of loose stick the ds3's sticks were perfect imo and the ds4's sticks feel too tight for me. But then again I am just used to the ds3 so who knows.

Not sure how it will play out this coming gen, but I personally enjoyed the 360 controller above the PS3 controller.

I find it odd how some people on here like it loose, usually people like it tight.. I like it tight