I personally liked Demon's Souls better than Dark Souls. I'm sure it will be good. But with next gen about to take all my attention I know anothe current gen game won't impress enough to make my list. Prety sure Last Guardian will be a PS4 title as well now.

1: Pokemon Diamond. 

Simply because I've spent over 800 hours on it, and it's the only game I've played for more than 200 hours. There shouldn't be much to discuss there.

2: Super Mario Galaxy 2

Amazing game, amazing soundtrack, amazing everything. Probably is the most perfect game I've ever played. I can't come up with one thing that the game did in a bad way. It's also the main reason as to why I bought number 4 on the list, since it made me listen to video game music. 

3: Endless Ocean 2

A really obscure game. But it's an fantastic one. There were so much to do, and almost every part of it was relaxing, and the parts that weren't were usually good in some other way. The game deserves more cred than it gets. 

4: Xenoblade Chronicles. 

The revival of the old Final Fantasy. Good art style, fantastic soundtrack, amazing world and the best story in any video game I've played. 

5: Mario Kart Wii

I feel it's kind of wrong to put this game so high up on the list, since it's far from perfect in any way. However, the amount of fun I've had with the game makes up for it. We have yet to invent a game that is better for parties than this one.

6: Skyrim

7: Skyward Sword

8: Twilight Princess

9: Super Mario Galaxy

10: Metroid Prime Triology.

Nope. I've never been interested in this series.

I like how after the fifth game you just gave up explaining thing and then merely listed them xD

Apparently having played the game is crucial to understanding why this is so epic..
that felt dull and was imo. a pretty booring song..  :) to each his own i guess.

Quick question: are you a huge Call of Duty fan? 

Fav console games of this gen.
1.The Last of Us (I put TLOU 1st only because it was a new IP and because it has better multiplayer from U2)
2,Uncharted 2
3.Unchated 3 (fav multiplayer game.....and I have played a lot of them)
4.Dark Souls
5,6,7,8,9,10 in no particular order (FF13,MGS4,Ni No Kuni,LBP.Uncharted 1,GOW 3)

Nope, not a COD fan @ all.
to namedrop some favourites: Galaxy 1&2, Zelda(series), Planescape Torment, BaldursGate (series), Fallout(series), ElderScrolls(series)

good enough? :P, why did you ask? that I was boored by him not shooting everything at sight?, it was dull music & horse-riding
(yes, played around in RDR @ a friends house, so i've played some of it)

I liked it better, because I'm lazy :D

Seriously though, they deserve their place, but I didn't feel for explaining it. They are there mostly for the same reasons as the ones over, just not being as good as them.

Can't agree with Super Mario Galaxy 2. I've always felt the second game is totally overrated, as in, is essencially the same game as the first one. (You can argue that the game deserves the same score because of that, but I'd prefer if they have gone using the New Super Luigi U route).

Can't argue with the rest of your choices, though :D