good to see PS3 win out one of the biggest games after all the beatings it took on DF this gen and b/c i'll get the PS3 if it never comes to next gen, 20fps 720p jaggies everywhere no thanks bring it to next gen R*

From the same page:

"The comparison has inaccuracies, thomas mentions filtering when they're identical in that regard some people have screen caps of the same spots in the screenshots with the textures loaded. so they're pretty much on par unless you count the small framerate advantage.

dunno whats going on in the gif above either LoD differs or asset is slower to load (see palm trees). this faceoff was rushed and they chose the winner so arbitrarily"

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=82364521&postcount=602

those trees

There is hardly a difference in that comparison above. The nitpicking is unbearable.

360 version's trees look better. Weird...

My version has 1 more tree in the scene than your version. Clearly I am a superior human being for having chosen the version I did.

why do guys even bother posting here? alot of your posts and sources are from there, VGC is banned there so why are we advertising them here so frequently a thread topic is one thing but basic posts now?

if either of you read the DF article its clearly displays the differences in palm trees (and even has a pic similar to ethomazs where you can compare the two palm trees side by side) and notes 360 superiority in that area but still did not affect there overall result 

It is not similar... it is the DF pictures... I won't post something not related to the thread.

look i can do it too, i dont need gaf to make posts/threads here

point is DF did the comparison took the time and has the equipment to do this analysis and originally came up with, credit should go to them

"Grand Theft Auto 5 begins at the beach, where a montage of Los Santos' visual high points shows object detail is a complete match between PS3 and 360. Palm tree tops are the one exception to this rule, and curiously boast a more lavish appearance on 360.

"

i have an active account on gaf since early 08 which probably dates back earlier than either of you, when i come on VGC i dont see the point of seeing GAF this and neo gaf that, i dont care whats going on there these forums need to get there originality back, johnlucas's recent thread is a good ex.

 I always credit the source and the place where I found the news, in this case: gaf. Its perfectly normal, dont be so upset.