By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Is “GPU Acceleration” Xbox One Secret Sauce?

ClassicGamingWizzz said:
you guys still creating threads about secret sauce ? xboone is a console or chicken wings ?


Isn't secret sauce white, creamy and taste salty?

OT: It really is interesting reading all these articles about how the Xbox One can be more powerful. I don't understand why people are getting so uptight about discussing possibilities. Even though I don't think there is a mind blowing secret sauce. I do believe this article holds some truth. M$ hasn't finalized APIs yet. These early games are running in most likely straight up generic code. Nothing that makes use of the beautiful harmony of everything working together.







VGChartz♥♥♥♥♥FOREVER

Xbone... the new "N" word   Apparently I troll MS now | Evidence | Evidence
Around the Network
Zappykins said:
SvennoJ said:
 

That audio FUD again. Sony said that down the road the GPU can be used for other things, like ray-casting, during downtime between frames, to show how flexible the GPU is. They didn't tell developers that they have to do their sound processing on the GPU at all.

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-face-to-face-with-mark-cerny
Now when I say that many people say, "but we want the best possible graphics". It turns out that they're not incompatible. If you look at how the GPU and its various sub-components are utilised throughout the frame, there are many portions throughout the frame - for example during the rendering of opaque shadowmaps - that the bulk of the GPU is unused. And so if you're doing compute for collision detection, physics or ray-casting for audio during those times you're not really affecting the graphics. You're utilising portions of the GPU that at that instant are otherwise under-utilised. And if you look through the frame you can see that depending on what phase it is, what portion is really available to use for compute.


http://blog.games.com/2013/07/23/sony-explains-how-developers-will-unlock-full-potential-ps4/

Cerny describes how the PS4 will be ready for the future and claims that the full power of the next-gen console will increase as the years go by. He explains what will happen when the PS4 launches as well as what will occur several years down the road.

The interview did get technical, though, so we've devised a list on what was discussed:

  • At the beginning of the PS4 cycle, most games will not unlock the PS4′s full potential.
  • Earlier PS4 Games will use "straight forward" features of the console, like its visual power and bandwidth.
  • Later on, the GPU will be used for many other objectives besides processing graphics
  • The GPU can do things like "physics, simulation, collision detecting or ray casting for audio or the like."
  • The extra stuff will not make the visuals worse.
  • "Some of these phases [within a frame of animation on-screen] don't really use all of the various modules within the GPU."
  • When there is free space on the GPU modules, it will have room for other tasks.
  • It will "improve the quality of your world's simulation without decreasing the quality of your graphics."


And this is what Sony said in April

http://techreport.com/news/24725/ps4-architect-discusses-console-custom-amd-processor
Cerny says the PS4's custom silicon incorporates not only the CPU and GPU, but also a "large number of other units." The chip has a dedicated audio unit to perform processing for voice chat and multiple audio streams. It also has a hardware block designed explicitly for zlib decompression. The main processor is backed by a secondary chip that enables an ultra-low-power mode for background downloading. In that mode, the CPU and GPU shut down, leaving only the auxiliary chip, system memory, networking, and storage active.

A 256-bit interface links the console's processor to its shared memory pool. According to Cerny, Sony considered a 128-bit implementation paired with on-chip eDRAM but deemed that solution too complex for developers to exploit. Sony has also taken steps to make it easier for developers to use the graphics component for general-purpose computing tasks.

secret sauce!

OK, so the screen going blank, or switching to 'shadow mode' so every game looks like Limbo, so they can have cool game sound is a desired 'feature.'  Got it.

So "Sony considered a 128-bit implementation paired with on-chip eDRAM but deemed that solution too complex for developers to exploit."  Yea, I kinda feel bad for him.  He has done his best, and so much responsibility on his shoulders.  To bad they couldn't have incorporated it into the OS to work behind the scenes so it would enhance performance, without making it more complected to program.   I am thankful there is a some company in Washington that is doing just that.

And this "At the beginning of the PS4 cycle, most games will not unlock the PS4′s full potential."  So he is apologizing for the quality of games before they are even out.  Sure everyone knows games get better, but this, is just sounding so, I wish him comfort in his solace.

But hey, perhaps it's time for Crash Bash 2. 

You deserve a spin throphy.

This GPU acceleration article from the OP is pretty much exactly the same thing as Sony's statements. Both have a flexible, programmable GPU that can be utilized for other tasks, and both have the use of extra processors for basic tasks.

MS states it, it will be so much faster, secret sauce
Sony states it, screen goes blank to have cool sound, they're too incompetent to make complex solutions work.

Yet who is reportedly behind on their SDK tools and recently had a launch game that needs a complete overhaul of its sound design.



Imaginedvl said:
bananaking21 said:
Imaginedvl said:
bananaking21 said:
this is just getting beyond sad

No, it is just a thread about the Xbox One for Xbox enthousiasts. The only sad thing here is you posting that kind of pathetic comment in every single Xbox thread. If you do not like them, just ignore these threads, I see plenty of thread talking about the PS4 and its features, I do not think you find anything "sad" about them...


did i hurt your little feelings? do you get this upset every time somebody says something you dont like that you have to call them pathatic? whats getting sad is the million threads and rumors that have no relevance or truth behind it that say that the xbox one is more powerfull than it really is. we are getting rumor after rumor, theory after theory and they are getting debunked one after one. the fact that all these xbox fans just cant accept that the PS4 is more powerful than the xbox one is sad, what makes it even more sad is that the xbox one is still a powerful console, but its these billions of bogus romurs and silly threads that make the situation rather, yes you guessed it, beyond sad. 

Edit @bolded: this thread is NOT for the xbox "enthousiasts" its for everybody, just because its an xbox related subject does not mean i can connot comment in it and its dedicated for a certain part of the members on the forum. when a thread is made its made for everybody on the forums, thats why we are here. if you want a thread that is for the xbox enthousiasts go to the xbox nation thread. if you cant accept the fact Sony, nintendo and PC fans have the right to express their opinion in xbox related thread maybe you are better off singing up on the forums on xbox.com 

1) Where did I say anything about "you" being pathetic? If someone seem to have some feeling issue, it is not me here :)
2) Again, did I said anything about non-Xbox enthousiasts not having the right to read/post in this thread? Not really... Only said this thread is actually targetted at those people...

Now, it is because the PS4 is more powerfull or because you think Sony is an half-god that we cannot talk about the "other" things out there without being called out by people like you who do not only like their console/company but ALSO hate the other one up to the point of ruining any discussion arround it...

Nothing to do about my feelings; just about threads with good discussions (or speculations) being completly invaded by haters who have NO interrests at all in the actual topics but to bash/troll/flamebait it... If it is that ridiculous to talk about speculations/rumors etc... Why are you even bothering reading them and commenting on them? Just ignore them and give us a break lol...

I have to plus you on this point.  Most times people like to discuss the merits of certain articles and their points.  Its more sad when you get fanboys who just want to throw out the fanboy spec sheets and LOLs to derail topics.  Even though I do not believe a lot of these topics, I like discussing their merits.  If I have nothing to add then I pretty much do not waste my time commenting.  Even this article, I thought the logic was very suspect but was interested to see any anyone had any points to raise on the merits or non merits.



Zappykins said:

OK, so the screen going blank, or switching to 'shadow mode' so every game looks like Limbo, so they can have cool game sound is a desired 'feature.'  Got it.

So "Sony considered a 128-bit implementation paired with on-chip eDRAM but deemed that solution too complex for developers to exploit."  Yea, I kinda feel bad for him.  He has done his best, and so much responsibility on his shoulders.  To bad they couldn't have incorporated it into the OS to work behind the scenes so it would enhance performance, without making it more complected to program.   I am thankful there is a some company in Washington that is doing just that.

And this "At the beginning of the PS4 cycle, most games will not unlock the PS4′s full potential."  So he is apologizing for the quality of games before they are even out.  Sure everyone knows games get better, but this, is just sounding so, I wish him comfort in his solace.

Bizarre.. yust when we thought misterXmediaspeak was out the door, a new voice appears on the horizon......



Wow. Come on people. Everyone just shot down this thread without even trying to discuss what the thread was about.



Around the Network
DJEVOLVE said:
richardhutnik said:
bananaking21 said:
this is just getting beyond sad

I am having a feeling like I am in an echo chamber with deja vu.  Didn't I read this secret sauce article in another thread on here, or is this the same thread?

Let's see, word I am seeing out of people on the Microsoft forum is that the PS4 and ONE's third party are the same.  So, let's see, I can get AT LEAST the same quality between third-party stuff on both platforms and the PS4 is $100 cheaper?  Am I supposed to be in love with Kinect 2.0 to not get a PS4 instead of a ONE?

Someone fill me in here on what I am missing.  Or, is it Ryse (the answer to God of War on Microsoft platform) or Killer Instinct reboot supposed to make a difference?


So you don't like it, Good for you. Go talk up Ps4 games. Point being, why are you even in hear if you don't care. Obvious you do or you wouldn't hit on the thread. So ask your self the questiong again. Maybe since you always come in these threads, you really want a xbox one. i

Personally I think XBox One games crush PS4 but hey thats my opinion. SHould I go into every PS4 thread and say this Like you do?

This popped up in the list of threads on the side, and I SWORE it was posted about and debunked, so I was asking if it was the same thread or different thread.  So, with this secret sauce debunked, I have to ask WHY someone would prefer the ONE over the PS4, and why I should, considering all things?  This comes from someone on here was clearly in the XBOX camp before the ONE release news debacle.  I am not a Sony guy really, just someone off the ship, so I have ever reason to ask what I ask.  I don't think you can even answer, because what I ask has no answer.  Well, maybe I missed Quantum Break.



fighter said:
richardhutnik said:
Imaginedvl said:
bananaking21 said:
this is just getting beyond sad

No, it is just a thread about the Xbox One for Xbox enthousiasts. The only sad thing here is you posting that kind of pathetic comment in every single Xbox thread. If you do not like them, just ignore these threads, I see plenty of thread talking about the PS4 and its features, I do not think you find anything "sad" about them...

Thing is I believe this information has come up in other threads, so it is not new, and is considered suspect.  So, it would be sad to rehash suspect information over and over again, as if cheerleading.  It is also sad that someone who is a videogame player needs to have such information to boost their morale.

1/ which other thread ? If so just signal there is a duplicate.

2/ ... considered suspect ? so you are denying this officially announced chips are a fake or that the interpretation of their use is erroneous ?

3/ as long as the X1 has the best line-up how could morale be low ? if it ends up being the more powerful it´s just a bonus

1. The second GPU was discussed in multiple other threads, including this one:

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=168016&page=1

I recall seeing "secret sauce" mentioned in what was another thread, regarding this.

2. The idea of the second chip is considered VERY suspect at this point.

3. Morale IS low, in regards to guys on here who care about sales and rooting for the XBOX ONE.  There has been a failure to come up with competent evidence that the more expensive ONE is superior to the PS4.  People can try to spin Kinect, but the core of people here don't care about it.  If the price points were reverse between the ONE and the PS4, it wouldn't be a big deal.  But it is the opposite of that, so it is an issue.  This isn't just about what one enjoys playing, but whichever one will sell the best.



richardhutnik said:
fighter said:
richardhutnik said:
Imaginedvl said:
bananaking21 said:
this is just getting beyond sad

No, it is just a thread about the Xbox One for Xbox enthousiasts. The only sad thing here is you posting that kind of pathetic comment in every single Xbox thread. If you do not like them, just ignore these threads, I see plenty of thread talking about the PS4 and its features, I do not think you find anything "sad" about them...

Thing is I believe this information has come up in other threads, so it is not new, and is considered suspect.  So, it would be sad to rehash suspect information over and over again, as if cheerleading.  It is also sad that someone who is a videogame player needs to have such information to boost their morale.

1/ which other thread ? If so just signal there is a duplicate.

2/ ... considered suspect ? so you are denying this officially announced chips are a fake or that the interpretation of their use is erroneous ?

3/ as long as the X1 has the best line-up how could morale be low ? if it ends up being the more powerful it´s just a bonus

1. The second GPU was discussed in multiple other threads, including this one:

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=168016&page=1

I recall seeing "secret sauce" mentioned in what was another thread, regarding this.

2. The idea of the second chip is considered VERY suspect at this point.

3. Morale IS low, in regards to guys on here who care about sales and rooting for the XBOX ONE.  There has been a failure to come up with competent evidence that the more expensive ONE is superior to the PS4.  People can try to spin Kinect, but the core of people here don't care about it.  If the price points were reverse between the ONE and the PS4, it wouldn't be a big deal.  But it is the opposite of that, so it is an issue.  This isn't just about what one enjoys playing, but whichever one will sell the best.

1 - this is not about a POTENTIAL second gpu but EXISTING video encoding and video decoding processors

2 - see 1

3 - games look awesome - morale is high



fighter said:
richardhutnik said:
fighter said:
richardhutnik said:
Imaginedvl said:
bananaking21 said:
this is just getting beyond sad

No, it is just a thread about the Xbox One for Xbox enthousiasts. The only sad thing here is you posting that kind of pathetic comment in every single Xbox thread. If you do not like them, just ignore these threads, I see plenty of thread talking about the PS4 and its features, I do not think you find anything "sad" about them...

Thing is I believe this information has come up in other threads, so it is not new, and is considered suspect.  So, it would be sad to rehash suspect information over and over again, as if cheerleading.  It is also sad that someone who is a videogame player needs to have such information to boost their morale.

1/ which other thread ? If so just signal there is a duplicate.

2/ ... considered suspect ? so you are denying this officially announced chips are a fake or that the interpretation of their use is erroneous ?

3/ as long as the X1 has the best line-up how could morale be low ? if it ends up being the more powerful it´s just a bonus

1. The second GPU was discussed in multiple other threads, including this one:

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=168016&page=1

I recall seeing "secret sauce" mentioned in what was another thread, regarding this.

2. The idea of the second chip is considered VERY suspect at this point.

3. Morale IS low, in regards to guys on here who care about sales and rooting for the XBOX ONE.  There has been a failure to come up with competent evidence that the more expensive ONE is superior to the PS4.  People can try to spin Kinect, but the core of people here don't care about it.  If the price points were reverse between the ONE and the PS4, it wouldn't be a big deal.  But it is the opposite of that, so it is an issue.  This isn't just about what one enjoys playing, but whichever one will sell the best.

1 - this is not about a POTENTIAL second gpu but EXISTING video encoding and video decoding processors

2 - see 1

3 - games look awesome - morale is high

1 - Yes sony doesn't have video encoding/decoding processors.

2 - Sony don't now what sound is, my PS3 games are all monochannel

3 - When morale is high you don't need daily motivational speech.



duduspace11 "Well, since we are estimating costs, Pokemon Red/Blue did cost Nintendo about $50m to make back in 1996"

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8808363

Mr Puggsly: "Hehe, I said good profit. You said big profit. Frankly, not losing money is what I meant by good. Don't get hung up on semantics"

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=9008994

Azzanation: "PS5 wouldn't sold out at launch without scalpers."

Keep fighting the good fight, Adinnieken