Well, the Xbox One got better line up so he is right about that.
As far as the reason why people are buying systems, I have some doubts :)

Let see which one is more important this November, better lineup or better price.

The people that look at the specs with technical jargon to buy a system are mostly on forums and they're handful compared to the whole market.

Microsoft continue to reiterate that spec differences are meaningless. If this dGPU rumour had any credence, i'm sure MS would be keeping quiet about specs being irrelevant. The exclusive games line-up is entirely subjective and hasn't even been set in stone yet. TGS yet to come and as Sony have proven with the PS3, it's the overall support over a platform's lifetime that is important, not launch window. Speaking of which, PS4 launch window destroys the PS3's.

Pretty much this.

I have to agree that Forza 5 is good enough reason to buy Xbone but it's just that for me.

Outside F5 both line-ups are equal.

It was never the tech stats that gamers hated about Xbone. It was the loss of choice in retail vs digital.

Now that this is gone, Xbone should be fine... so long as $500 is an ok price point.

lol

How would we know?

Wii U has both of them...

I disagree. I think they both have bad line-ups.

Wich one is better depends on personal taste.