It's a start, but I'm not that impressive. I'd give it a 7- out of ten. But this seems to be the short spot, there may be a longer one that works better and ties in with this one.
First off, song seems just terrible. Not the worst I have ever heard, but eek. Anyone can hold their nose and try to sing, then pass through auto tune.
Second, it doesn't make it clear enough what the Xbox One will do for you. You need to educate your consumers, I don't think it does enough of this. I learn from it I can skype someone outside who wears a blue shirt overacts and waves their arms in the air.
Third, why don't they show the product at the end? I get the logo, but should see the product.
Fourth, I think with ALL commercials should be able to know what it is without watching it. Like someone getting popcorn in the other room. Or in this case, beer.
Now, they probably have a longer one, that is hopefully better. It may tie in and help with some of the things I stated.
Also, they should totally make another Football one for Europe, including the UK. (Yes, the other football.)
(Just realized he may have insulted friends, ops.)