By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Xbox One Strikes Back

Microsoft's redemption in the eyes of consumers means it can finally let the games do the talking.


Before we can get our hands on them, the impending arrival of new games consoles has inevitably descended into a war of words between platform holders, as Sony and Microsoft desperately exchange multi-million dollar punches in an effort to gain the slightest PR advantage.

 

Before this week's Gamescom there was one clear champion in the marketing slugfest, but while Sony is yet to be totally usurped from its position of power, it's telling that it's no longer the outright belt-holder either.

Perhaps the greatest shift of power was evident during a single moment of the German show. It wasn't the two Phils' revelation that every Xbox One pre-order in Europe will be rewarded with a free copy of FIFA, or even the cautiously welcomed indie self-publishing policy.

No, Xbox One's biggest sign of redemption yet came when Sony Computer Entertainment boss Andrew House made an uncharacteristically gauche attack on Microsoft's flip-flopping policies... only to be met with an awkward silence and limp applause from his audience.

Two months ago Sony's E3 Xbox snipes - including that comedy pre-owned games video - made the firm the champion of gamers. But now, following a gargantuan rescue effort from Microsoft (which included the unsurprising departure of scapegoat boss Don Mattrick) Sony's digs feel as out of date as an old Xbox One fact sheet.

For me, games boss Phil Spencer was right this week when he defended Microsoft's decision to react to the early outrage over One policies.

The prime ammunition in Sony's marketing musket has been to target Microsoft's numerous 180 manoeuvres - from used games policies, to online requirements and the mandatory Kinect sensor - as costly defeats.

But in the crossfire it seems to have missed the fact that, to the man on the street, these corporate three-point-turns - however embarrassing for Microsoft - have simply resulted in an Xbox One that's far more attractive today than when we first saw it in that damp Xbox Tent.

In just a few short months the next-gen Xbox has been repackaged from a machine which needed to be online, to having no such requirement. The old digital-focussed used games policy has been abolished, while the bundled Kinect sensor no longer needs to be connected in order for the console to operate.

The price and relatively closed platform were the final pieces of the puzzle, and the Redmond firm tackled both issues this week with varying levels of success, mostly dependent on whether or not you like FIFA. And if you do like FIFA then that £80 / $100 price difference between Xbox One and PS4 suddenly doesn't look quite so bad.

What does this mean? With the pink (or is that green?) elephants safely back in their cages, it feels fantastic that for the first time in six months the public gaze has seemingly shifted from company policy to what's actually exciting about the console transition: the games.

Most journalists I speak to agree that this is where Microsoft's machine looks particularly strong; It's hasn't quite got the 'best launch line-up in history' Phil Harrison believes it does, but Xbox One's smart mix of first-party titles, combined with high profile CoD, FIFA and Battlefield content exclusives could prove decisive when the public make their next-gen buying decisions this Christmas.

Sony's software roster isn't half bad either of course, plus it's offering what's possibly the most powerful, developer friendly console ever made.

There are still twists and turns to come in the road to November, with both platform holders lining up announcements for the coming weeks (and Xbox One doesn't even have a launch date yet), but for once we can feel safe in the likelihood that it's action, not words, which will be used to sell the next-gen of gaming.

Source



Around the Network

The games are meh though. I don't want a single one besides maybe call of duty ghosts. Titanfall looks like overrated crap, Destiny looks to be overrated crap, Halo made by 343i. If 343i can make a real halo game then I can't wait, but Halo 4 was terrible. When I see a game I want I'll get it, but right now I'm holding on to my 360. Even if I wanted Titanfall or Destiny they are coming to current gen. Not one of these games make $500 worth it.



Brace yourself for the inevitable onslaught of Haters.

My take away is the real bottom line point of this OP: let's quit jerking around about PR B.S., and play the games.



For me, it is certainly a new, different console than that one they advertise when Don Mattrick was still around.



teamsilent13 said:

The games are meh though. I don't want a single one besides maybe call of duty ghosts. Titanfall looks like overrated crap, Destiny looks to be overrated crap, Halo made by 343i. If 343i can make a real halo game then I can't wait, but Halo 4 was terrible.

I can literally take this part of your post and reverse every statement to express how I feel.

Games they showed for Xbox One look great. I want many of them, Crimson Dragoon, Dead Rising, Forza, Killer Instinct...pretty much everything except the new COD Ghosts which looks like same old crap. Titanfall looks jawdropping and I can't wait to play it. Halo 4 was great and the new Halo should be as well if the same 343 studios people are involved.



Around the Network

The really interesting thing about GamesCon is that it is an opportunity not just for the press to get hands on with the games, but also for gamers to. Unlike E3 or either reveal. While I know Microsoft has made an effort to give gamers the opportunity to play on the Xbox One, to see all the games at an event is where you can make a huge impression.

Which will be why PAX Seattle this year will be huge!!! Gamers in the US will have a chance to get there hands on the Xbox One and PS4 and actually play the games.



-

Last edited by Oliver4p1 - on 10 January 2026

Good for them.



 Next Gen 

11/20/09 04:25 makingmusic476 Warning Other (Your avatar is borderline NSFW. Please keep it for as long as possible.)

still not interested. Call me when they fix Ryse.



still not interested. Call me when they fix Ryse.wonder what you will try to use as an excuse next seeing as this one is getting oldddd,will you be interested if ryse is fixed?i think not.



Don,t be Fanboys,Be Gamefans,Play games 4ever...GAME ON(msn)