That was a well hosted round btw, Mario - thanks

I think if Nacho didn't lie about his role in the first place, we'd would have lynched Linkz one night earlier but who knows what would have happened after that. Radish did play mafia extraordinarily well. I didn't expect Sokka not to be an actual character since he is very integral to the story

IMO the game was really rigged in mafia's favor and it's a miracle that the whole thing came down to the wire like it did. Well done town!

supermario128 said: morenoingrato said: Lucky you. The characters at the end were sooo accurate. I know. I have no idea how it ended up that way. Haha.   Vetteman94 said: You didnt seriously give the mafia safe name claims did you?    Indeed, I did. Although, it didn't seem to help them very much. Radish's role claim is what seems to have saved him.

You do realize thats taking away one of the weapons a Town has, giving them freebie name claims that are safe makes it easy when its supposed to be difficult for a mafia to lie their way out of it.

Yeah without that lie I think we lynch Links that day as well.  There was really no need for it

I normally hate it when flavour is linked to roles but it was done so well this time round that it added to the overall experience, even if others will say it affected balance.

Having the vigilante being the Cabbage Merchant has to be my favourite of the characters haha, I'd completely forgotten about him until I saw the PM flavour about his cabbages being destroyed. You should have included Sparky Sparky Boom Man though :P

Vetteman94 said: supermario128 said: morenoingrato said: Lucky you. The characters at the end were sooo accurate. I know. I have no idea how it ended up that way. Haha.   Vetteman94 said: You didnt seriously give the mafia safe name claims did you?    Indeed, I did. Although, it didn't seem to help them very much. Radish's role claim is what seems to have saved him. You do realize thats taking away one of the weapons a Town has, giving them freebie name claims that are safe makes it easy when its supposed to be difficult for a mafia to lie their way out of it.

Flavor shouldn't be a weapon, it's decoration for the game. http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Safe_Claim

Town should have pressed radish's claim harder. Mafia(me) was the only one to question it at the start. And you never pushed for who was targeted on which Nights. radish claimed he was blocked the first Night he was in the game and benao died on his second Night. Your quote of benao's couldn't have been Friendly Neighbor related, and he even said it was 100% due to the flavor elsewhere.

Rolewise yes Mafia was stacked. trashleg could've carried out kills without fear of the Tracker/JoAT with radish using Strongman to deal with anyone that absolutely had to go. Godfather getting scanned could potentially be deadly as "confirmed" townie.(Another point where Town didn't do squat to look into what someone posted, though this time it helped) And having a Roleblock is of course huge to mess with Town's roles. On the other hand, mafia could have lost after the second Day if Town played perfectly.

What ended up happening was I did everything for two Days, helped solidify radish's claim, and took the fall so that he'd have a good chance on the final Day. Town shouldn't get the credit you're giving as it was a modkill that even forced it to be as close as it was.

I'll add your name to the list. Yoshi, DT, and Stefl all mentioned wanting to take a crack at hosting according to:http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=121381&page=1#

I'm locking up Round 60, but consider me auto-in for 59.

Linkzmax said: Vetteman94 said: supermario128 said: morenoingrato said: Lucky you. The characters at the end were sooo accurate. I know. I have no idea how it ended up that way. Haha.   Vetteman94 said: You didnt seriously give the mafia safe name claims did you?    Indeed, I did. Although, it didn't seem to help them very much. Radish's role claim is what seems to have saved him. You do realize thats taking away one of the weapons a Town has, giving them freebie name claims that are safe makes it easy when its supposed to be difficult for a mafia to lie their way out of it. Flavor shouldn't be a weapon, it's decoration for the game. http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Safe_Claim Town should have pressed radish's claim harder. Mafia(me) was the only one to question it at the start. And you never pushed for who was targeted on which Nights. radish claimed he was blocked the first Night he was in the game and benao died on his second Night. Your quote of benao's couldn't have been Friendly Neighbor related, and he even said it was 100% due to the flavor elsewhere.

Its not like the mafia needed anymore help then they got