About to read through 3-400 posts and take notes.

Yoshiya and Nacho are pretty safe town in my opinion having read the thread, but I think lynching Moreno is a terrible idea. Everyone has played pretty well this game as far as not being obv-Mafia goes, so the natural choice would be to lynch one of the players that isn't speaking very much. However, I'm still one of those (although I'm looking to change this), so I'm not fully behind this idea either.

Regardless, I'm pretty sure we're playing a pretty heavy power game right now, judging from what I've read and generally feeling from people's attitudes to the game. This means we must be very careful with our moves at all times!

Anyone who you think is more likely to be mafia than others?

Noctis and Benao

At this point I wouldn't oppose lynching moreno.

Everybody seems to have an structured defense on why they are town. Nacho claims that moreno's lurking might be a telling, and his response towards the accusations against him, are not that solid.

The problem is that a mislynch right now would cost us dearly.

Trashleg and radish, should catch up soon, and may provide some fresh points of view. But, I think that we have covered pretty much that can be discussed without mass role-claiming.

Care to elaborate?

As I said, everyone has been doing pretty well at staying low this round, so it's just a feeling. But I don't want to instantly believe any "town" scan this game, because if it's as power-heavy as I think it could be, the Mafia are definitely going to have a few tricks to mess around with us. That's not to say I don't believe that Linkz is an investigative role necessarily - although that could be the case too.

Why do you disagree with a massclaim? And why is bringing up a massclaim and putting a vote on you worthy of an HoS back?

Lynching moreno is a terrible idea because there aren't any obv-Mafia?

Who are your suspects?

Noctis voted Spurge right away - why? is this just an in-joke or was there a reason?

Stefl's role is unlikely to be truly revealed during the game, but I agree with everyone who said he's PROBABLY town. Although I don't get what powers he had to "know" certain people were town.

Beno seems to trust Vette, I don't trust Vetteman. You seem to be trying too hard sometimes. You also laid into Stefl before voting him, this doesn't make you a bad person but I'm curious as to why you had such a problem with him so early. Just for role claiming?

Stefl claimed linkz was town (IIRC). Since Stefl is dead and not a confirmed bad guy, I'll trust him on this one.

Spurge voted for nacho and I guess now is too late to ask him why.

Bena seems to have good intentions, says its "more costly not to trust Vetteman".

Spurge went off the rails. Argued with Vetteman. He really did seem cray cray so I can't fault ANYONE for voting for him. I mean jeez.

Favourite quote so far: "Spurge, regardless of your alignment, you're such a pain to read".

Nacho seems to be in the same predicament as me with regards to not being involved enough in these discussions.

Yoshiya, I had observations on you but I can't make my mind up.

Vetteman and/or Noctis probably the two I'd like to look into more/hear more about.

But it's nearly 1am.

Miller strongly implies there is a Cop as Tracker and Watcher are unaffected by a Miller.

Let's try this again shall we. Night 1 Noctis visited me and I visited Nacho. Noctis is confirmed town, to me at least, due to his role, not mine.