Its not. Its possible,  Its possible.

Thats possible as well.  

So instead of just making bold claims give me some information to back those up.  

All you are doing now is attacking an idea instead of coming up with a "better" one.

I visited everyone for the same reason, I thought they could be scum. Unfortunately, outside of a possible flavor hint it's unlikely I'll be able to confirm anyone unless it's later in the round.

For the sceond part I guess you could say i was role fishing.  The problem I am having is we seem to have a couple players with "cop like" roles.   Both you and Astro are claiming to have knowledge of the innocence of certain players.  I just find it odd that we, the town, would have that many roles to be able to do that.  Unless of course both of your roles had limitations.   Now you wouldnt know if you had a sanity limitation but you would know if you had a use limitation, so do you?

Something is really bothering me.....

We already have a Tracker confirmed, normally with a Tracker there is a Watcher role as well. Now with the 2 other people who are claiming to have "Investigation" type roles neither one sounds like a Watcher. As a Watcher you can't get innocence readings from the player only who visited them. Both people are claiming that people they visited are innocent, How they got that I have no idea.

Is it really possible that this game has as many as 3 or 4 investigation style roles, or is someone lying about what they did?

Given the game structure I am assuming, 3 Mafia 10 town originally, that if we don't lynch mafia today we will be at MYLO for day 4. Or even worse case scenario our 3rd party/SK/Vig kills again and puts us at LYLO. So it would be nice if we got this right tonight.

There's no way that so many investigative roles would exist in one game - unless they were heavily restricted, of course.

Thats what i am starting to think.  

If this game was twice the number of people like some of our older games, then yeah it would be entirely possible.  As I remember a few games where that happened.   But we are talking 13 people with 3 as investigation style roles, thats as big as the mafia team I suspected we had.

I think Linkz' role is more of a mason/recruiter, than a cop/watcher.

Astro said that his role wasn't a clear one, and yoshiya's theory about him being a Jack of all trades is sound.

No proper cop has roleclaimed right now, perhaps we don't even have one. Hopefully we do. Still, somebody said that Mario made a game with lots of powers, so it does make sense.

Unless the cop has scanned anyone that is guilty, it's probably not worth them claiming now (assuming there is one of course). They would just end up a target for the mafia and all we would have is 2 innocent scans which whilst helpful isn't as useful as a guilty scan. If the mafia were then to have a strongman then the cop would die no matter what.

With every day that goes by, any regular cop that could exist is more likely to be killed, but I think we have at least one more night before I would seriously suggest roleclaiming with the results they may have.

if there's going to be this much discussion about roles, we should probably massclaim. otherwise, it's about time we lynched moreningrato.

Vote: moreningrato