By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 58: Avatar The Last Airbender

Vote: Astrogamer

Yoshiya claiming a kill on someone who wasn't killed by the scumteam makes him very likely town. Who are your suspects, keeping that in mind? Please don't just give me the names of people who haven't posted yet...



Around the Network

Nice, no more dead people.

Waiting to see if Sm128 fills in the role for Stefl in the chart, just to see where we stand.

Currently my suspicions lie with Baalz, Noctis and Trashleg, they really aren't participating very much. Baalz and Trashleg are basically lurkers, with Noctis posts lacking anything of real substance. And in a game of what seem to be alot of power roles, it would be odd for a town person to not participate much because of that.

I don't like that Nacho is going around saying a few people are basically "confirmed town" without some evidence to back it up. Its odd he is so trustworthy of people. Would be nice if he elaborated on this.

Linkz, Benao, Moreno and Yoshiya I dont have too much of a read on. Some things here and there I see but nothing too much. They dont bother me as much as the "lurkers" are for the reason given above



Nachomamma8 said:
Vote: Astrogamer

Yoshiya claiming a kill on someone who wasn't killed by the scumteam makes him very likely town. Who are your suspects, keeping that in mind? Please don't just give me the names of people who haven't posted yet...


Where did he claim the kill? All he claimed was he was at Stefl's.  He could be a cop/ roleblocker/bus driver or a number of other different roles.  

Explain your vote?



Nachomamma8 said:
Vote: Astrogamer

Yoshiya claiming a kill on someone who wasn't killed by the scumteam makes him very likely town. Who are your suspects, keeping that in mind? Please don't just give me the names of people who haven't posted yet...

As Vette has already mentioned, I wasn't claiming the kill, I was just claiming that I was there. I'm going to wait for Noctis to return and confirm that me and Astro were the people at Stefl beforehand though because it might have been something completely unrelated, that just seemed the most logical reason for him to say me and someone else when I had been at someone who had died that Night.

Also, I think we can safely say any more nameclaims are a big no. If we did, Katara would be in massive danger from the mafia because she is almost definitely the doctor (something which again makes sense within the flavour meaning I hope none of the mafia know the series too well after my nameclaim Day 1 :G)



Ok, so yoshiya is town.

And 3rd party did not kill anyone, maybe he was absent and didn't sent the action, or he/she saved the kill for another night, judging from the flavour.

@yoshiya are you suggesting astro is a 3rd party? Why else would he be at stefl's.

@noctis feel like roleclaiming, or at least answering to yoshiya's reply.



Around the Network
benao87 said:

@yoshiya are you suggesting astro is a 3rd party? Why else would he be at stefl's.

If Noctis is indeed the watcher then yes, I believe astro is 3rd party.



NoCtiS_NoX said:
Yoshiya is my number 1 suspect right now.

HoN: Yoshi

followed by astro


You really need to respond to the situation.  

And these lurkers are getting ridiculous.



The doctor had good timing it seems.

Yoshiya... what do you mean that Astro was at Stelf's?



benao87 said:
Ok, so yoshiya is town.

And 3rd party did not kill anyone, maybe he was absent and didn't sent the action, or he/she saved the kill for another night, judging from the flavour.

@yoshiya are you suggesting astro is a 3rd party? Why else would he be at stefl's.

@noctis feel like roleclaiming, or at least answering to yoshiya's reply.

I wouldnt declare yoshiya town just yet.   He could be a Mafia Roleblocker.  

The 3rd party killer could have a limit to the number of kills they have,  given the size of the game that is very likely.  Chances are they were only a one shot possible two shots.   

I am hoping the killer is a Serial Killer and not a Vigilante, as I do believe there were better targets than Stefl for that kill.



Why are we assuming that Astro was at Stefls? I can't find who said this and what is their proof of this. All I see about Stefl is Yoshiya has claimed to have been there.