KI goodness. I hope these actions have a great impact on the popularity of the game.

Coming from a guy that has played it all:
GTA IV is better than all the Halo games, Naughty Dog games are really incredible. The only reason gears stands up to Naughty Dog tps games is because it is a co-op game.

I don't understand the GTA hate here. Its easily one of the best gaming franchises. GTA V is amazing.

Coming from a guy that has also played it all:

No

You went from GTA to Naughty Dog in just a geared halo comment.

Can't speak for rest, but gears destroys naughty dog TPS. I've played both. 

Yeah, I played GTA V on 360 over a year ago. It just simply  has a ton to do like they all do. The jumping between characters is fun, the humor is spot on good, as normal. The world is one of the best acheived in open world so far. Trevor is one of the most twisted and memorible characters in recent gaming history. The whole main storyline has a ton to do including the side quests. Not to mention GTA online can be pretty cool too and with the new heists finally added it offers a great co-op challenge to an already enormous game. 

Is soccer better than basketball? And Naughty Dog doesn't make TPS games. Try Third Person Adventure.

Well, I think it comes down to if you actually like the world of Gears or not. It was a great experience in the first game and was completely freash. At the time, it came out co-op and third person shooters were not as common, so the original was a great experience. The other games are fun too, but I am not a fan of the world and characters. Uncharted changes a lot in setting for each game and TLOUS changes setting a great deal and is different in that it has more stealth involved in it. As whole package I have to give Naughty Dog games a huge advantage. 

I like football over soccer and hockey over basketball.